Designing a Fuzzy Rule Based System to Estimate Depth of Anesthesia
V. Esmaeili
a
, A. Assareh
b
, M. B. Shamsollahi
a
, M. H. Moradi
b
and N. M. Arefian
c
a
Biomedical Signal and Image Processing Laboratory (BiSIPL), School of Electrical Engineering, Sharif University of Technology
b
Faculty of Biomedical Engineering, Amirkabir University of Technology
c
Department of Anesthesia, Shahid Beheshti University
Abstract- Estimating the depth of anesthesia (DOA) is still a
challenging area in anesthesia research. The objective of this
study was to design a fuzzy rule based system which integrates
electroencephalogram (EEG) features to quantitatively
estimate the DOA.
The proposed method is based on the analysis of single-channel
EEG using frequency and time domain features as well as
Shannon entropy measure. The fuzzy classifier is trained with
features obtained from four subsets of data comprising well-
defined anesthesia states: awake, moderate, general anesthesia,
and isoelectric. The classifier extracts efficient fuzzy if-then
rules and the DOA index is derived between 100 (full awake) to
0 (isoelectric) using fuzzy inference engine.
To validate the proposed method, a clinical study has
conducted on 22 patients to construct 4 subsets of reference
states and also to compare the results with CSM monitor
(Danmeter, Denmark), which has revealed satisfactory
correlation with clinical assessments.
I. Introduction
Depth of anesthesia assessment has remained a challenging
problem for several decades. It is because none of the
parameters used to this aim has satisfactorily described the
complexity of the system. Patient hemodynamics like blood
pressure, heart rate, tearing and sweating can not avoid
awareness and movements during surgery. Neither plasma
nor the effect site concentration of the drug can measure
clinical effects directly. Solving this problem the Central
Nervous System, the main target for anesthetic agents, has
received a great deal of attention and EEG-based methods
have been widely used for estimating the anesthetic depth.
Various types of features have been extracted from the
electroencephalogram to predict depth of anesthesia. Early
studies have used spectral edge frequency, median
frequency and the relative and total power in the classical
frequency bands [1]-[3]. Using parameters based on
bispectrum made a progress in EEG-based anesthesia
monitoring. The bispectrum power is said to indicate the
presence of quadratic phase-coupling between different
frequencies within the signal. Recently some researchers
have used EEG entropy measures as an indicator of depth of
anesthesia [4]-[7]. The concept behind this is that EEG
becomes more regular as the anesthetic depth increases.
Also Lempel-Ziv complexity of EEG has shown good
correlation with increasing the anesthetic depth [8].
Although these parameters can distinguish well between
awake and anesthetized states, they don’t behave
monotonically during transition from wakefulness to deep
isoelectric states [2]. So we can’t utilize them individually
to continuously monitor anesthetic state changes during
different phases of anesthesia. Concerning this, some efforts
have been made to combine these features using
computational intelligence techniques such as neural
networks and neuro-fuzzy inference systems [5], [9-10].
In the present study we have proposed a rule-based fuzzy
logic system merging different EEG derived measures to
obtain an index for the depth of anesthesia. Several studies
have introduced adaptive neuro-fuzzy inference system
(ANFIS) as a powerful tool for classifying DOA. Although
it led to good compatibility with clinical assessments, but
the black box nature of neural learning makes these systems
rigid to importing knowledge from human expert that may
improve the performance of the system. Moreover, it is
difficult to drive knowledge from artificially made rules of
these systems. Considering the above mentioned problem
we decided to use a fuzzy inference system (FIS) that was
initially established by human expert and then optimized by
machine learning procedures.
Two trends can be observed in development of anesthesia
monitors. Some algorithms put more emphasis on some
advanced parameters like bispectrum or entropy, while the
others (like CSM, Cerebral State Monitor) combine some
well-known spectral ratios and time domain characteristic of
EEG applying them to a classification algorithm. CSM
(Danmeter, Denmark) is a recently developed depth of
anesthesia monitor having good correlation with clinical
assessments. It uses 3 later defined spectral ratios: alpha-
ratio, beta-ratio and difference between them, which is
called theta ratio in this paper, accompany with burst-
suppression, a time domain feature relating to deep iso-
electric states. Each of these components is affecting in a
specific range of anesthetic level where they perform best.
Adaptive Neural Fuzzy Inference System (ANFIS) is used
to calculate the CSI which is a scalar index changing
between 0 and 100. In this study we utilized features used in
calculating CSI and also SEF and Shannon entropy in
681
Proceedings of the 2007 IEEE Symposium on
Computational Intelligence and Data Mining (CIDM 2007)
1-4244-0705-2/07/$20.00 ©2007 IEEE