Seeing Landscape Through Cross-Cultural Eyes:
Embracing a Transcultural Lens Toward Multilingual
Design Approaches in the Landscape Studio
Shenglin Chang
Shcrif^lin Chang is currently
Assistant Professor at the University
of Maryland's Landscape
Architecture Program, and received
the C.ELA Award of Recognition in
2004. Professor Chang was awarded
a PhD in Knvironmental Planning
from University of ("alifornia,
Berkeley, an MiA from Coj iiell
University, an MS in Civil
Engineering and a BS in
Horticulture from National Taiwan
University. Her research focuses on
high-lech (Silicon Valley) landscapes
in the Pacific Rim and the transfor-
mations of immigrant home identi-
ties in the DC-Maryland region. Her
book, The (Uohal Silicon Valley Home:
Lives and Landscapes xvithin Taiioane.se
American Trans-Pacific Culture, is
fortlic<jming from Stanford
University Press.
Abstract: I his article reflects on the value of atltivating transcuUural aivareness in
design education. The term "transcultural lens " is derived from the emeiging critical con-
cept of transculturality, or the intermingling of one's domestic culture with many other
foreigii cultures. 'This concept relates to the melding and mixing of cultural elements
expressed by a group of Amnican students in the University of Maryland's Land.scape
Architecture Program who worked on the Taiwanese Chi Chi Earthquake Memmial Park
Competition, design. Wiien these students examined their own American lens in designing
a Taiwanese memimal park, the transformation of this lens allowed them to matiipulate
design patterns and languages of their natixie culture (Ameiican) and the newly encoun-
tered culture ('Taiwanese) in an innovative yet sensitive way. This generated a new
design approach that I am callingAmerican-yet-Taiwane.se; that not only distinguished
the unique quality and practices of different cultures, Imt also blended these cultures
together in an (evolutionary luay.
S
ince the 1980s, rapid tech-
nological transformations
occurring in countries around the
world have not only initiated the
information age (Castells 1996,
1997, and 1998), but also have
fueled a transnational bi-gration
(two-way immigration) phenomenon
not seen in previous eras (Chang
forthcoming; Levitt 2001; Lima
2001: Smitb 1998). These transfor-
mations affect tbe nature of 21'''-cen-
tury communication and travel and
include phenomena sticb as afford-
able air transportation, widely acces-
sible World Wide Web connections,
instant messaging, and IP and wire-
less phone service. They have pro-
foundly impacted how we perceive
our native and foreign cultures, and
accelerate the intermixed relation of
different cultures. Philosopher
Wolfgang Welsch argues that we live
in a transcultural context. He states
that, "Lifestyles no longer end at the
borders of national cultures, but go
beyond these. . . . There is no longer
anything absolutely foreign. . . .
Today, in a culture's internal rela-
tions—among its different ways of
life—there exists as much foreign-
ness as in its external relations with
other culttires" {1999, 197-198).
Cultural geographer Yi-Fu Tuan
adds to the recognition of an emerg-
ing transcultural world: "tbe life-
path of a buman being moves
natiirally from 'bome' to 'world,'
from 'hearth' to 'cosmos.'" (1996, 2)
Transculturality in Land.scape Design
Tbe concept of "transculttiral-
ity" articulates more clearly tbe new
phenomenon of cultural intermix-
ing tbat we are seeing in today's
interconnected world (Welsch
1999), The concept assumes perme-
able culttiral boiuidarics as opposed
to thinking of cultures as isolated
islands or enclosed spheres. The
term "transcultural lens" is derived
from tbe emerging concept of
transculturality; wbicb makes a break
from previous concepts of multicul-
turalism. Welsch points out that
tbose traditional concepts of cul-
tures—including classic single cul-
ture, interculturalism, and
multiculturalism—assume that
"every culture can be distinguished
and remain .separated from otber
folks' cultures'* (1999, 195).
However, he argues transculturality
"sketches a different picture of tbe
relation between cultures, not one
of isolation and conflict, but one of
entanglement, intermixing, and
commonness" (205). Tbe concept of
transcTilturality is different from that
140 Landscape Journal 24:2-05
Landscape Journal'ii-.t-Qb ISSN 0277-2426
© 2005 by the Board of Regents of the University of Wisconsin System