Approaching Biomimetics: Optimization of Resource Use
in Buildings using a System Dynamics Modeling Tool
Mercedes Garcia-Holguera, Grant Clark, Aaron Sprecher, and Susan Gaskin
McGill University
Montreal, Canada
{maria.garciaholguera, grant.clark, aaron.sprecher, susan.gaskin}@mcgill.ca
ABSTRACT
The biomimetic field in architecture is developing tools for
transferring processes and functions from biological
systems to buildings. Buildings, like ecosystems, are
dynamic and complex systems, thus studying their
dynamics from a systems thinking perspective might bring
insight to some environmental problems. STELLA®, a
software commonly used to model environmental
dynamics, was used to identify approaches for energy
optimization in the Great River Energy Building. Long-
term energy flows and thermal properties of the building
were modeled to understand the feedback loops that control
the behavior of the building system. The simulation showed
that optimization of passive building parameters produced
considerable energy savings, but more active strategies
would be necessary to make the Great River Energy
building a net-zero energy building. This exercise showed
how the STELLA® software can represent the dynamic
behavior of buildings as well as the dynamic behavior of
environmental systems, and the potential of this tool for
biomimetic research in architecture.
Author Keywords
Biomimetics; biomimicry; ecomimetics; net-zero building;
system dynamics; STELLA
INTRODUCTION
Biomimetic research is rooted in the idea that there is great
opportunity for innovation in learning from Nature. The
primary goal of biomimetic research is to transfer
knowledge from biology to human technology [1]. In
architecture, biomimetic research is recent, and according
to the categorization by Pedersen Zari [2] it might mimic
organisms, behaviors and ecosystems. The latter,
mimicking of ecosystems, is also known as ecomimetics
[3], and refers to the transfer of processes and functions
from ecosystems to architectural systems. Ecosystems are
complex systems where interactions among biotic and
abiotic elements occur. From a thermodynamic point of
view, ecosystems are open systems that modulate inflows
and outflows of energy, matter, and information. Similarly,
buildings are also thermodynamic open systems that behave
as complex systems. According to the general systems
theory [4], systems from different fields may share
structural characteristics and show similar behavior [5]. An
ecomimetic approach presumes that structural organization
and behavior of ecosystems might be transferred to and
reproduced by architectural systems. The work presented
here is part of a bigger effort to define a systematic
ecomimetic method that optimizes resource use in
buildings. A central part of this effort consists of the
identification and development of transdisciplinary tools
that might help to communicate the ecological and
architectural fields. One approach identified for this
purpose is system dynamics. The field of system dynamics
was first developed by Forrester [6] at the Massachusetts
Institute of Technology while studying feedback control
theory. System dynamics is used to model the complex
behavior of systems (e.g. ecosystems) by representing the
feedback interactions happening among sub-systems.
Although system dynamics is not a predictive tool, it helps
to describe trends of the system under study, and it might be
used in a varied number of fields such as environmental
modeling, health care, organization of military forces, or
management of natural disasters [7, 8]. System dynamics
has also been implemented as a decision-making tool in the
building and construction industry. Among these
applications some are focused on sustainable construction
and energy efficiency [9-12]. Dyner et al. [9] use a system
dynamics approach to identify appropriate energy policies
in an urban context. Shen et al. [10] analyze the feasibility
of construction projects using iThink®, which is a modeling
tool based on system dynamics focused toward a business
audience. Oladokun et al. [11, 12] use another tool,
Vensim®, to model the dynamic feedbacks of household
energy consumption in UK. None of these examples focus
on a single building analysis; however, there is great
potential for resource use optimization in buildings by
implementing system dynamics in architectural design.
This document presents how the STELLA® software tool
[13], traditionally used for modeling dynamic systems [7]
can be a suitable transdisciplinary tool for modeling
building systems for ecomimetic design, and a valuable
decision-making tool for optimization of resource use in
buildings. The purpose of this exercise is to show the
potential of this modeling tool within the building industry
rather than provide exhaustive and exact results. Therefore
data used in the modeling exercise might be considered
general or not specific enough for the building under study
since the priority of this work is to evaluate the overall
performance of the tool.
SimAUD 2015, April 12 - 15, 2015, Alexandria, VA, USA
© 2015 Society for Modeling & Simulation International (SCS)
1055