International Journal of Mechanical & Mechatronics Engineering IJMME-IJENS Vol:15 No:06 9
150804-1505-5959-IJMME-IJENS © December 2015 IJENS
I J E N S
Abstract— The manufacturing process of drilling is considered
the most efficient method for opening holes in a variety of
materials. The present research aims to study the effects of the
drilling parameters such as cutting speed, feed rate and tool
diameter used on the prediction of the total thrust force and the
thrust force due to the cutting action of the tool’s main cutting
edges. The experiments were carried out by varying the drilling
parameters and the output responses were mathematically
modeled based on the response surface methodology. The
analysis of variance was used to verify the adequacy of the
mathematical models. The most significant input variables were
recognized and the 3D response surfaces were plotted.
Index Term— Al7075, drilling, response surface methodology,
thrust force.
I. INTRODUCTION
DRILLING is the most commonly used machining operation
in a variety of materials. The quality of the drilled holes is
significantly affected by the developed thrust force.
A number of researchers have been applying the response
surface methodology (RSM) to different manufacturing
environments. RSM is a tool for determining the cause and
effect relationship between responses and input variables [1].
The basic steps involved can be summarized as follows:
Designing of a set of experiments for adequate and
reliable measurement of the response.
Determining the mathematical model with the best
fitting.
Finding the optimum set of experimental factors that
maximize/minimize the response.
Represent the effects of the variables on the response
using 2D or 3D plots.
This research has been co-financed by the European Union (European
Social Fund – ESF) and Greek national funds through the Operational
Program "Education and Lifelong Learning" of the National Strategic
Reference Framework (NSRF) - Research Funding Program: ARCHIMEDES
III. Investing in knowledge society through the European Social Fund.
The paper was submitted in June 2015
P. Kyratsis is with the Technological Education Institute of Western
Macedonia, Department of Mechanical Engineering and Industrial Design,
Kila Kozani, GR50100, Greece (e-mail: pkyratsis@teiwm.gr).
N. Taousanidis is with the Technological Education Institute of Western
Macedonia, Department of Mechanical Engineering and Industrial Design,
Kila Kozani, GR50100, Greece (e-mail: taousan@teiwm.gr).
A. Tsagaris is with the Technological Education Institute of Thessaloniki,
Department of Automation Engineering, P.O. Box 141, GR57400,
Thessaloniki, Greece (e-mail: tsagaris@autom.teithe.gr)
K. Kakoulis is with the Technological Education Institute of Western
Macedonia, Department of Mechanical Engineering and Industrial Design,
Kila Kozani, GR50100, Greece (e-mail: kkakoulis@teiwm.gr).
II. REVIEW OF LITERATURE
Onwubolu et al. presented a mathematical model for
correlating the interactions of speed, feed rate and drill
diameter on the axial force and torque, acting on the cutting
tool during drilling. They implemented the response surface
methodology with a three-level full factorial design. The
results proved that the model can be used for optimization
purposes in order to minimize both the axial force and torque
[2].
Li et al. drilled a 15mm thick recombinant bamboo and
considered the spindle speed, feed rate and diameter for the
measurement of both the thrust force and torque.
Mathematical models were developed resulting that the main
influence on the thrust force came from the spindle speed and
feed rate, while for the torque, the diameter of the tool and the
spindle speed were the most significant parameters. High
spindle speed with low feed rate minimized the thrust force
[3].
Krishnaraj et al. investigated the thrust force and surface
roughness of plain carbide drill with drill parameters (drill
diameter, spindle speed and feed rate) in drilling carbon fibre
reinforced plastic (CFRP) laminate/aluminum stack. Taguchi
method and the L
27
orthogonal array were used together with
the analysis for variance (ANOVA). Feed rate and diameter
were the most significant drill parameters. In addition, when
the feed increases the circularity increases as well [4].
Prakash and Planikumar studied the use of Taguchi and
response surface methodology for predicting the surface
roughness in drilling medium density fiberboard (MDF)
material by physical vapor deposition TiN coated carbide step
drill bits. The drilling parameters used were the spindle speed,
feed rate and drill diameter. The effect of these parameters on
the surface roughness was evaluated and discussed in details.
A second order model was established for calculating the
surface roughness from the cutting parameters. Validation
experiments were performed in order to examine the accuracy
of the proposed models [5, 6].
Sundeep et al. examined the drilling behavior of austenitic
stainless steel (AISI316) and optimized the process parameters
using L
9
orthogonal array from the Taguchi methodology.
Spindle speed, feed rate and drill diameter were used as input
parameters, while the lowest thrust force and highest metal
Drilling Mathematical Models Using the
Response Surface Methodology
Panagiotis Kyratsis, Nikolaos Taousanidis, Apostolos Tsagaris, Konstantinos Kakoulis