International Journal of Electrical & Computer Sciences IJECS-IJENS Vol:10 No:05 22
104605-9494 IJECS-IJENS © October 2010 IJENS
I J E N S
Abstract— The aim of this paper is to investigate and detect the
multiple faults in machines using broken rotor bar and
eccentricity fault frequencies techniques. It is proposed that using
both current and instantaneous power signals simultaneously, will
detect the multiple faults reliably, specifically using broken rotor
bar fault frequencies and eccentricity fault frequencies under
various load conditions. The analyses carried out in this paper
show that the current spectra is able to detect multiple faults i.e. a
combination of broken rotor bars and eccentricity faults either by
using broken rotor bars fault frequency components (1±2s)f1 or
using eccentricity fault frequency components (f1±fr) at any levels
of loading. The results from the instantaneous power spectra
using modified broken rotor bar fault frequency components
(fp±4f2) show that it is preferable for estimating either the
machines having multiple faults. It can be concluded from the
results that flux signal is also not a useful source to detect
multiple faults using both broken rotor bar and eccentricity fault
frequency components.
Index Term— Broken Rotor Bar, Eccentricity, Electric
Machine, Multiple Faults.
I. INTRODUCTION
THE basis of any condition monitoring depends on
understanding the electric, magnetic and mechanical behavior
of a machine in both the healthy and faulty state [1]. An
induction machine is highly symmetrical and the presence of
any kind of fault modifies its symmetry and produces changes
in the measured sensor signals, or more precisely, in the
magnitude of certain fault frequencies [2].
In induction motor monitoring single sensor is normally used
to detect a single fault. Previously, the correlation between
different types of sensors and their ability to diagnose multiple
faults has not been studied thoroughly enough in the literature.
The most prevalent faults in machines are broken rotor bar,
stator or armature, misalignment, eccentricity and bearing
related faults (bearing fault can also cause rotor eccentricity [3,
4]. Therefore, characterization and accurate prediction of the
1
Dr. Intesar Ahmed,
1
Engr. Muhammad Shuja Khan and
1
Engr. Kashif
Imran are with Department of Electrical Engineering, COMSATS Institute of
Information Technology, Lahore PAKISTAN. (Emails:
drintesarahmad@ciitlahore.edu.pk, shuja@ciitlahore.edu.pk,
kashifimranciitlahore.edu.pk).
2
Engr. Manzar Ahmed is with Department of Electrical Engineering,
University of South Asia, Lahore PAKISTAN.
performance degradation for the induction machine under
such conditions is of considerable importance. However, the
technology in this field is still in permanent evolution and new
techniques appear every year. The purpose of this trend is to
be more efficient in fault detection and to provide a reliable
method with low-cost sensors and simple numerical
algorithms. It is the reason why most international conferences
dedicated to electrical machines make room for sessions on
monitoring and diagnosis.
Condition monitoring of induction machines relies on being
able to detect differences between healthy and faulty machines.
An accurate interpretation of a motor’s condition requires
knowledge of the effects of different operating conditions
(including level of loading, non-ideal supplies), and typical
variability between machines and test repeatability.
The localized heating caused by the fault will gradually result
in further insulation damage until the motor fails. It is useful to
be able to detect such faults at an early stage so that a pre-
planned shutdown can be arranged for the motor to be
replaced by a healthy motor. Various causes of stator and rotor
failures have been presented and discussed in detail. A specific
methodology is proposed to facilitate an accurate analysis of
these failures [5]. Although, condition monitoring is normally
done for induction motors [6], and it can also be carried out
for induction generators as-well [7].
A comprehensive literature review of more than 20 existing
methods, including the most common methods to assess the
phase-to-ground, phase-to-phase, and turn-to-turn insulation
conditions are presented in [8 - 11]. The use of fault frequency
components in the current, flux and vibration sensor signals to
try to both detect and estimate the severity of static eccentricity
faults in the presence of load variations and the detection of
Eccentricity Fault in machine have been reported in [12, 13].
The purpose of this paper is to investigate fault frequencies in
motors with multiple faults to be able to detect and to uncover
the most prevalent that may occur in machines. The airgap
between the rotor and stator of a healthy motor (2kW) used in
this study is 0.4 mm (each side). Therefore, airgap of ±1, ±2
and ±3 mm at the driving and at non-driving-end are
considered for the experiment.
The investigation of multiple faults (combination of broken
rotor bars and eccentricity faults) at different levels of loading
will be involving the following:
Investigation of Multiple Faults Detection in
Electric Machine Using Broken Rotor Bar and
Eccentricity Fault Frequencies Techniques
Intesar Ahmed
1
, Manzar Ahmed
2
, M. Shuja Khan
1
, Kashif Imran
1