Abstract The aim of the present study was to describe
the fibre architecture of the fetal heart at mid gestation,
and to clarify some persistent controversies concerning
the architecture of the myofibres in the right ventricular
wall and the muscular ventricular septum. We used quan-
titative polarized light microscopy to obtain information
about the orientation of myocardial cells in the ventricu-
lar mass. These cells, joined into a network by anasto-
moses, have at any point in the ventricular mass a princi-
pal direction – the fibre direction. We have quantitated
this information in the form of maps of the azimuth and
elevation angles, in 18 midgestation fetal hearts. Our
findings show that the fibre architecture of the heart can
be conceptualised as myocardial fibres running like geo-
desics on a nested set of warped “pretzels”. This model
is an extension to the whole ventricular mass of Krehl’s
Triebwerk, and Streeter’s model which was restricted to
the left ventricle. A “pretzel” itself can be considered as
two doughnuts joined side-by-side, with the tunnel at the
center of each doughnut corresponding to the ventricular
cavity. Over and above the excellence of the fit between
the data and the geodesic representation, three strong ar-
guments support this model. First, it is the only existing
model that explains the observed rolling over of fibres
around the atrioventricular valvar orifices. Second, it ex-
plains the trajectory of the fibres from the epicardium to
the endocardium at the basal parts of both ventricles and
at the apical part of the left ventricle. Third, the predict-
ed topological singularities of the model are systemati-
cally observed in each of the 18 hearts studied.
Key words Myocardium · Heart ventricle · Microscopy ·
Polarization · Topology
Introduction
The organization of myofibres has been extensively
studied in the mammalian heart, and numerous models
have been proposed. In general terms, two different fam-
ilies of models can be distinguished (Fig. 1). In the first
family, the arrangement of the myocardial fibres is given
by analogy with the description of the arrangement of
the muscular skeletal fibres. Thus, the fibres are consid-
ered to gather in distinct bundles and muscles, with each
fibre retaining a close individual relationship with the
cardiac fibrous skeleton. These models distinguished
from one to four systems of myocardial bundles (Mall
1911; Benninghoff 1931; Robb and Robb 1942; Lev and
Simkins 1956; Torrent-Guasp 1975). In the extreme
case, Robb and Robb (Fig. 1A) proposed an arrangement
of four myocardial bundles anchoring on the fibrous trig-
ones and the aortic and pulmonary roots, Torrent-Guasp
in contrast (Fig. 1B) considered only one system, which
he argued was composed of the unrolled ventricular
walls being stretched between the aortic valve at one end
and the pulmonary valve at the other. The limitations of
these models, mostly based on dissection, have been
stressed recently (Lunkenheimer et al. 1997; Schmid
et al. 1997; Torrent-Guasp et al. 1997). In the second
family of models, the myocardium is viewed as a spe-
cialization of the vascular musculature, with myocardial
fibres branching from one to another, rather than taking
their origin or insertion from the fibrous skeleton. This
approach was initiated by Krehl (1891) at the end of the
19 century. It has been considerably reinforced by signif-
icant advances that, by means of photonic and electronic
microscopy, showed the myocardial fibres to be a net-
work of preferentially oriented and branched myocardial
cells forming end-to-end cellular junctions (Hort 1960,
1971; Fox and Hutchins 1972). Among these models,
some have focused essentially on the architecture of the
P.-S. Jouk (
✉
) · G. Michalowicz · L. Grossi
UF Biologie du développement et Génétique clinique,
Centre Hospitalier Universitaire de Grenoble, BP 217,
38043 Grenoble cedex 9, France
e-mail: pierre-simon.Jouk@ujf-grenoble.fr
Tel.: 33 (0)476765482, Fax: 33 (0)476768850
P.-S. Jouk · Y. Usson · G. Michalowicz
Equipe Reconnaissance des Formes et Microscopie Quantitative –
Laboratoire TIMC, UMR5525 CNRS, Institut Albert Bonniot,
Faculté de Médecine, Université Joseph Fourier, Grenoble I,
Domaine de la Merci, 38706 La Tronche Cedex, France
Anat Embryol (2000) 202:103–118 © Springer-Verlag 2000
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Pierre-Simon Jouk · Yves Usson
Gabrielle Michalowicz · Laurence Grossi
Three-dimensional cartography of the pattern of the myofibres
in the second trimester fetal human heart
Accepted: 23 March 2000