UNCORRECTED PROOF
Marine Pollution Bulletin xxx (2017) xxx-xxx
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Marine Pollution Bulletin
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com
Perturbation of sea!oor bacterial community structure by drilling waste discharge
Tan Thi Nguyen , Sabine K.J. Cochrane , Bjarne Landfald
Norwegian College of Fishery Science, Faculty of Biosciences, Fisheries and Economics, UiT The Arctic University of Norway, Breivika, N-9037 Tromsø, Norway
Akvaplan-niva AS, Polar Environmental Center, 9296 Tromsø, Norway
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Drill cutting
Sea!oor
Bioindicator
Microbiota
Barents Sea
ABSTRACT
O#shore drilling operations result in the generation of drill cuttings and localized smothering of the ben‐
thic habitats. This study explores bacterial community changes in the in the upper layers of the sea!oor re‐
sulting from an exploratory drilling operation at 1400 m water depth on the Barents Sea continental slope.
Significant restructurings of the sediment microbiota were restricted to the sampling sites notably affected
by the drilling waste discharge, i.e. at 30 m and 50 m distances from the drilling location, and to the upper
2 cm of the sea!oor. Three bacterial groups, the orders Clostridiales and Desulfuromonadales and the class
Mollicutes, were almost exclusively con%ned to the upper two centimeters at 30 m distance, thereby corrob‐
orating an observed increase in anaerobicity in!icted by the drilling waste deposition. The potential of
these phylogenetic groups as microbial bioindicators of the spatial extent and persistence of drilling waste
discharge should be further explored.
1. Introduction
Drilling for oil and gas generates quantities of waste that origi‐
nate from the release of drilling muds and rock cuttings, collectively
referred to as drill cuttings, and often also excess cement or other
materials used. The amount of waste depends on the drilling depth,
and the environmental impact of this discharge depends on its quan‐
tity and composition, local oceanographic conditions and the dis‐
charge strategy adopted. Since the early 1990s, the Norwegian envi‐
ronmental regulatory authorities have prohibited the discharge of
drill cuttings using oil-based drilling muds, such that either water
based muds or closed systems are used. The oil content of released
drill cuttings with accompanying drilling mud residuals should not
exceed 1%. Materials exceeding this threshold level are slurri%ed and
reinjected or transported onshore for cleanup. Hence, the drilling
waste currently deposited on the sea!oor in the vicinity of the
drilling sites largely comprises rock debris, mineral weight material
(e.g. barite, ilmenite) and smaller amounts of residual, water-soluble
chemical components. As baseline levels of barium (Ba) in sediments
are generally low, the barite-derived Ba is commonly used as a sensi‐
tive tracer of dispersal and persistence of discharges from drilling op‐
erations (Kennicutt et al., 1983; Phillips et al., 1998; Ellis et al.,
2012).
Although the environmental impacts of the discharges of water-
based drill cuttings are considerably less than those of the previ‐
ously-used oil-based varieties (Bakke et al., 2013), mesocosm and
%eld experiments have demonstrated effects on the benthic macro‐
fauna (Schaanning et al., 2008; Trannum et al., 2010). As might be
expected, the intensity of these effects is dependent on the thickness
of the deposited layer. However, contrary to previous assumptions,
oxygen depletion, anticipated to be induced by microbial catabolism
of organic components in the drilling !uids, seems to have a stronger
negative impact on the benthos than the plain burial effect caused by
drill cuttings sedimentation (Trannum et al., 2010). The radius of se‐
riously affected benthic communities coincides rather closely with
the visually evident spread of drilling waste and is rarely reported to
extend beyond 100–200 m. The affected area is furthermore shown
to diminish gradually over time after termination of the drilling op‐
erations (Daan et al., 2006; Gates and Jones, 2012; Jones et al.,
2012).
Only few studies have been published on the microbiological ef‐
fects of drilling muds and cuttings deposition, and their focus has
largely been on the consequences of using oil-based muds. In a North
Sea %eld study, Sanders and Tibbetts (1987) demonstrated increased
hydrocarbon-degrading and sulfate-reducing activity as far out as
500 m from the center of a drill cuttings pile if aromatics-rich diesel
based drilling muds were employed, whereas less toxic aliphatics
Corresponding author.
Email address: bjarne.landfald@uit.no (B. Landfald)
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.marpolbul.2017.10.039
Received 28 June 2017; Accepted 18 October 2017
Available online xxx
0025-326/ © 2017.
a b a, ⁎
a
b
⁎