Focaal—Journal of Global and Historical Anthropology 90 (2021): 22–35
© Te Authors
doi:10.3167/fcl.2021.900103
Te Janus face of austerity politics
Autonomy and dependence in contemporary Spain
Susana Narotzky
Abstract: How is social reproduction possible in a context of precarious employ-
ment and austerity policies that have defunded welfare? Te paradox of autonomy
and dependence is present in intergenerational relations of support and confict
at various scales. It emerges, on the one hand, in the neoliberal injunction to be
individually responsible for one’s own present and future wellbeing, an aspiration
that is impossible to fulfll. On the other hand, it is expressed in the increasing
recourse by younger active cohorts to the care work and assets of their older kin—
in particular retirement pensions and a home. Finally, policy calls to transform
the pension system oppose younger and older generations in the accountings of
social security fnancial sustainability and question the fairness of existing public
pension schemes.
Keywords: class struggle, entrepreneurial self, generations, kinship, neoliberalism,
pension, privilege, social reproduction
“Who gives shelter to a couple with two chil-
dren if not your parents? It is very tough, be-
cause with 40 years that I have they cannot treat
me as if I had 14 . . . and that I have to depend
on my parents . . . when I have a husband and
children and supposedly I should have an au-
tonomy . . . and you go back to being 15 years
old and being in your mom and dad’s home,
with everything that it implies . . . because since
then [when you were 15] you already are 40 years
old.” Marta is unemployed and has been living
with her parents since 2010 when, unable to pay
the mortgage on an apartment she and her hus-
band had bought, the couple was evicted. Even-
tually, they divorced, the ex-husband moved to
another region of Spain, and he stopped provid-
ing alimony. She stayed with the children at her
parents while she enrolled for various training
courses and tried to fnd odd jobs, even as she
tried to get fnancial aid from various institu-
tional schemes. She confded to me in 2013 that
she hates having to “depend” on state “aid”: “I
don’t want any aid, what I want is work,” she an-
grily asserts.
Marta is among a generation of younger
adults in Ferrol (Galicia) that have come to de-
pend on their parents’ willingness to house them,
share their income with them, and care for their
children. She speaks of her parents’ generation
misapprehension of her situation: “Tey expe-