A Fresh Look at the Crystal Violet Lab with Handheld Camera
Colorimetry
Theodore R. Knutson,
§,†
Cassandra M. Knutson,
§,‡
Abbie R. Mozzetti,
†
Antonio R. Campos,
†
Christy L. Haynes,
†
and R. Lee Penn*
,†
†
Department of Chemistry, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55455, United States
‡
White Bear Lake High School, White Bear Lake, Minnesota 55110, United States
* S Supporting Information
ABSTRACT: Chemical kinetic experiments to determine rate
laws are common in high school and college chemistry courses.
For reactions involving a color change, rate laws can be
determined experimentally using spectrophotometric or colori-
metric equipment though this equipment can be cost
prohibitive. Previous work demonstrated that inexpensive
handheld camera devices can be used to quantify the
concentration of a colored analyte in solution. This paper
extends this approach to the kinetic study of the color fading of
crystal violet upon reaction with sodium hydroxide. The results
demonstrate accurate determination of the reaction order, with
respect to crystal violet, using a method accessible in many high
school and college laboratories.
KEYWORDS: High School/Introductory Chemistry, First-Year Undergraduate/General, Hands-On Learning/Manipulatives, Kinetics,
Laboratory Equipment/Apparatus, Analytical Chemistry, Physical Chemistry, Dyes/Pigments
M
ost high school and college students have some practical
knowledge about speeds of reactions before taking a
chemistry course. For example, students understand that foods
cook faster at higher temperature. This knowledge is supported
and extended by the study of chemical kinetics. While studying
kinetics, students learn that rate laws for chemical reactions can
only be determined experimentally. Experiments suitable for
exploration of kinetic concepts are essential for building
connections to the curriculum. Rate laws can be determined
by measuring initial rates or monitoring concentration over
time.
Monitoring changes in concentration of a colored analyte in
solution can be accomplished through spectrophotometry or
colorimetry. Traditional equipment used for these measure-
ments can cost hundreds to thousands of dollars per
instrument; many high schools do not have the financial
means to purchase such instrumentation. Recently, Kehoe and
Penn published a method for performing quantitative color-
imetry using handheld camera devices.
1
Their work demon-
strated suitable precision and accuracy; thus, quantitative
colorimetry can be performed even in the absence of traditional
equipment.
Crystal violet, an intensely violet-colored triphenylmethane
dye, reacts with hydroxide ions in aqueous solution to form a
colorless compound (Scheme 1). For years, this reaction has
been successfully used as a lab exercise for the experimental
determination of a rate law.
2,3
A large excess of sodium
hydroxide relative to crystal violet is used, which means that the
reaction’s rate depends only on the concentration of crystal
violet. Analytical spectrophotometry or colorimetry is per-
formed at specified time intervals. Students monitor the
concentration of crystal violet, which fades over time, by
Scheme 1. Reaction Scheme between Crystal Violet and
Hydroxide Ions
a
a
Structures (a) and (b) are two resonance structures of crystal violet
before the reaction, and structure (c) is the colorless product of the
reaction.
Laboratory Experiment
pubs.acs.org/jchemeduc
© XXXX American Chemical Society and
Division of Chemical Education, Inc. A DOI: 10.1021/ed500876y
J. Chem. Educ. XXXX, XXX, XXX-XXX