Pinnacle Agricultural Research & Management
http:/www.pjpub.org
© Author(s) 2014. CC Attribution 3.0 License.
Research Article
Institutional bricolage as a new perspective to analyse institutions of communal irrigation:
Implications towards meeting the water needs of the poor communities in rural Ethiopia
Tekalign Gutu¹, Sam Wong² & Wole Kinati³*
¹International Food Policy Research Institute,
Eastern and Southern Africa Regional Office,
Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
²School of Environmental Science,
University of Liverpool, UK.
³Researcher
Oromia Agricultural Research Institute, Ethiopia.
ABSTRACT
Access to water supply in Ethiopia is one of the lowest in the world. In response, Ethiopia has developed a 15-year water development project
for the period 2002-2016 in order to enhance appropriate and comprehensive water use policies and related institutional arrangements. The
objective of this paper is to analyze the institutional aspects of communal irrigation in Ethiopia using the concepts of institutional bricolage.
Based on two case studies and intensive literature review, the trust to ensure that the poor communities achieve economic efficiency, social
equity in access to water and ecological sustainability simultaneously through the adoption of 'institutional crafting' does not seem to
correspond with reality. It then challenges the universal application of the 'design principles' approach for its inadequacy in explaining the
realities underlying the institutional formation of communal irrigation where collective action is more complex. The paper argues that the
concept of institutional bricolage is an alternative approach to understand the dynamics and complexities of institutions in irrigation
development. In the face of growing demands of irrigation water, there are key issues to consider through the lens of bricolage for appropriate
development interventions aimed at institutional building: acknowledging the complexity of institutional building, ecological stress, historical
factors, power relations, gender, access to other institutions and cultural repertoires embedded in the community. Development interventions
which recognise the importance of the processes of institutional bricolage have great potential of success and enhance sustainable use of
natural resources.
Keywords: institutional bricolage, institutional crafting, irrigation, Ethiopia
Volume 2014 (2014)
Accepted 14 January, 2014
1. INTRODUCTION
Access to water supply in Ethiopia is one of the lowest in the
world (World Bank, 2006). According to the World Bank , in
2008, only 38% of the population have access to improved
water (World Bank, 2010). In 2006 the Bank conducted a
study to estimate the magnitude of the impacts of high water
variability on growth and poverty. The study finds that the
effects of water variability reduced projected rates of
economic growth by 38% per year and increased projected
poverty rates by 25% over a twelve year period. In response,
Ethiopia has developed a 15-year water development project
for the period 2002-2016 in order to enhance the appropriate
and comprehensive water use policies and related
institutional arrangements. Among the water sectors
agricultural water use has got the most attention through the
strategy called Agricultural Development Led
Industrialization (ADLI). The intervention of the plan is to
address most of the supply-demand gap within 15 years time
through increasing the number of large, medium and small
scale irrigation schemes in rural areas where 80 % of the
population live (World Bank, 2010). In addition, the
Government recognizes, community managed small-scale
irrigation water schemes as viable alternative to privatization
and state ownership of the resource (Water Sector
Development Program of MoWR, 2003). This is expected to
increase the role of local communities in resource
management.
Locally, there are different institutional arrangements for
irrigation water management; examples include use of "water
masters" and executives of water users' associations.
Establishing appropriate water management institutions and
strengthening capacity of water management organizations
is expected to bring efficient and equitable distribution of
irrigation water for beneficiaries, thus contributing to
increased productivity (Ostrom, 1990; 1992; WSDP, 2003;
World Bank, 2003; 2004). However, most of these resources
are exploited on a first come, first-served basis which results
in the inefficient utilization of the resources and inequalities
Corresponding Author: Wole Kinati³*
Researcher, Oromia Agricultural Research Institute, Ethiopia.
Email address: wolekinati@gmail.com