Participatory adaptation to climate extremes: an
assessment of households’ willingness to contribute
labor for flood risk mitigation in Pakistan
Azhar Abbas, T. S. Amjath-Babu, Harald Kächele and Klaus Müller
ABSTRACT
The predicted increase in frequency and severity of flooding events poses substantial challenges for
the farming communities of developing countries. Given the financial limitations of governments in
these countries, the concept of participatory flood management is of high relevance. This article
studies how communities can participate in structural measures such as embankments/dikes. Given
that surplus rural labor is available due to the seasonal nature of agricultural operations, this paper
utilizes a field survey for exploring the willingness to contribute (WTC) labor by rural households in
Pakistan towards a hypothetical flood-protection scheme. Results show a potential labor
contribution of 11.07 man-days per year per household (equivalent to Rs. 4,084 or 39 USD). The WTC
decision is positively influenced by the number of adult family members, livestock damage,
compensation received and expected effectiveness of the intervention, but is negatively influenced
by age and education of the household head, farm income and the distance of the farm from the
river. The study concludes that community resources (e.g., manual labor) can be utilized for flood
mitigation, which may reduce the costs of building and maintaining the infrastructure while
increasing the sense of security and ownership. This would also ensure the sustainability of flood
protection interventions to a considerable extent.
Azhar Abbas (corresponding author)
T. S. Amjath-Babu
Harald Kächele
Klaus Müller
Leibniz Centre for Agricultural Landscape Research
(ZALF),
Eberswalder Str. 84,
Müncheberg 15374,
Germany
E-mail: azhar.abbas@zalf.de; azharuaf@gmail.com
Azhar Abbas
University of Agriculture,
Faisalabad 38040,
Pakistan
Key words | adaptation, climate, Contingent Valuation Methodology, disaster, efficacy, intervention
INTRODUCTION
Extreme climate events like floods are projected to increase
in frequency and intensity in the future (Hirabayashi et al.
). Despite several technological advancements, these
events are causing significant physical destruction and econ-
omic damage to societies (Coumou & Rahmstorf ; Kazi
). Fluvial flooding is a major type of flood disaster that
inflicts large scale damages in developing countries,
especially in South Asia, due to the presence of several
major river systems (ICIMOD ) in the region. In
addition, heavy reliance on conventional flood control prac-
tices by these nations exacerbates the impacts of riverine
floods (Shaw ). India, Bangladesh and Pakistan, three
neighboring South Asian countries, have suffered heavily
due to flooding disasters in last few decades. Despite a
long history of flooding, a number of factors render these
nations (especially Pakistan) less successful in devising sus-
tainable solutions to manage these extreme events (Kale
). An important factor among them is the under-utiliz-
ation of local knowledge and community resources like
labor.
Government bodies, international donor agencies and
non-governmental organizations (NGOs) are investing size-
able capital and energy in cushioning the impact of flooding
disasters (both as ex-ante and ex-post) but the sustainability
of these interventions still remains in question (Pearce ;
ICIMOD ). It is surprising that the possibility of
621 © IWA Publishing 2016 Journal of Water and Climate Change | 07.3 | 2016
doi: 10.2166/wcc.2016.002
Downloaded from https://iwaponline.com/jwcc/article-pdf/7/3/621/373391/jwc0070621.pdf
by guest
on 12 July 2020