[CANCER RESEARCH 64, 8788 – 8793, December 1, 2004]
Folate Is Associated with the Natural History of High-Risk
Human Papillomaviruses
Chandrika J. Piyathilake,
1
Olga L. Henao,
2
Maurizio Macaluso,
2
Phillip E. Cornwell,
1
Sreelatha Meleth,
3
Douglas C. Heimburger,
1
and Edward E. Partridge
4
Departments of
1
Nutrition Sciences,
2
Epidemiology and International Health,
3
Biostatistics, and
4
Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Alabama at Birmingham, Birmingham,
Alabama
ABSTRACT
Several micronutrients have been implicated in cervical carcinogenesis.
However, their mode of action is still a matter of speculation. In partic-
ular, it is unclear whether certain nutrients reduce the probability of
acquiring high-risk human papillomavirus (HPV) or whether they facili-
tate the clearance of high-risk HPV. We conducted a 24-month prospec-
tive follow-up study to test the hypothesis that systemic concentrations of
folate are associated with the occurrence and duration of high-risk HPV
infections after controlling for other micronutrients (vitamins B
12
, A, E,
and C, total carotene) and known risk factors for high-risk HPV infections
and cervical cancer. Circulating concentrations of these micronutrients
and risk factors for cervical cancer were determined in a cohort of 345
women who were at risk of developing cervical intraepithelial neoplasia.
Using the hybrid capture 2 (HC-2) assay, high-risk HPV status was
evaluated at 6-month intervals up to 24 months. All women had at least
three consecutive visit high-risk HPV test results. Higher folate status was
inversely associated with becoming HC-2 test-positive [odds ratio (OR):
0.27; 95% confidence interval (CI), 0.08 – 0.91; P 0.04]. Women with
higher folate status were significantly less likely to be repeatedly HC-2
test-positive (OR: 0.33; 95% CI, 0.13– 0.86; P 0.02) and more likely to
become test-negative during the study (OR: 2.50; 95% CI, 1.18 –5.30;
P 0.02). To our knowledge, this is the first long-term prospective
follow-up study reporting an independent protective role of higher folate
status on several aspects of the natural history of high-risk HPV after
controlling for known risk factors and other micronutrients. Improving
folate status in subjects at risk of getting infected or already infected with
high-risk HPV may have a beneficial impact in the prevention of cervical
cancer.
INTRODUCTION
Worldwide, cervical cancer is second only to breast cancer as the
most common malignancy in both incidence and mortality (1, 2). In
the United States, it accounted for an estimated 12,900 new cases and
4,400 deaths in 2001 (3). The introduction of the Pap smear test by
George Papanicolaou in 1943 allowed for the study of precursor
lesions of cervical cancer and has led to cervical dysplasia becoming
one of the most widely studied precancers (4). In much of the world,
cervical cancer is diagnosed in women in their thirties and has a major
impact on the stability and social adhesion of families. The incidence
of cervical cancer is likely to increase over the next several decades as
women in the developing world begin to age and as the number of
women infected with HIV increases (5). Cervical intraepithelial neo-
plasia (CIN), which precedes cervical cancer, have also reached
epidemic proportions, with an estimate of at least 600,000 new cases
per year in the United States (6).
Although an infection with high-risk human papillomavirus (HPV)
is probably a necessary cause for CIN and cervical cancer (7–9), most
of the epidemiologic evidence comes from retrospective, case-control
studies, which do not shed light on the dynamics of cervical HPV
infection and its progression to cancer (10). Recent interest in assess-
ing the potential for screening high-risk HPV as a replacement or
augmentation of cervical cytology and in developing HPV vaccines
have compelled the initiation of longitudinal studies of the natural
history of HPV infections and cervical lesions (11–17).
Factors that may play a role in HPV acquisition include a higher
number of sexual partners, high frequencies of vaginal sex, alcohol
consumption and certain characteristics of partners (12), sexual be-
havior (rate of new partners), non-white race and use of hormonal
contraceptives (18), younger age, Hispanic or black ethnicity, history
of herpes simplex virus infection, and history of vulvar warts (11). It
is likely that many of these factors are indicators of exposure to
HPV-infected partners or of increased susceptibility to transmission.
Most high-risk HPV infections are transient because of its clearance
from the affected tissues. Although the factors that may enhance or
influence the clearance of high-risk HPV are important in reducing the
risk associated with this virus, lifestyle factors that govern HPV
clearance are poorly understood.
Infection with high-risk and multiple types of HPV and older age
have been shown to be risk factors for HPV persistence (18). In turn,
persistent HPV infection is a likely mechanism of persistence of
cervical dysplasia (19 –21) and the progression of HPV-infected le-
sions to cervical cancer (15). The associations with persistent infec-
tion and multiple types of infection could be associated with certain
characteristics of these subjects, which predispose them to persistent
infection. Women who are immunosuppressed by infection with the
HIV are at risk for infection with multiple types of HPV (22). It is also
possible that the reduced immunocompetence associated with defi-
ciencies of micronutrients, including folate (23, 24), is likely to
modify the natural history of HPV infections.
Several short-term studies assessing limited numbers of nutrients to
evaluate the significance of micronutrients in the natural history of
HPV have resulted in inconsistent results. Effects of higher concen-
trations of trans- and cis-lycopene in reducing the time to clearance of
oncogenic HPV infections in United States women (25), an associa-
tion between lower serum -carotene, -cryptoxanthin, and lutein
concentrations and HPV persistence among United States Hispanics
(26), and an association between low plasma vitamin B
12
concentra-
tions and persistent HPV infection among Hispanic women (27) have
been reported. A small study among Hispanic women, however, did
not support a role for folate, vitamin B
12
, or homocysteine in HPV
persistence or cervical dysplasia (28). Palan et al. (29) found no
associations among circulating concentrations of retinal, - and -car-
otene, or lycopene and persistent HPV infections. The aforementioned
studies were shorter term (3 to 10 months) than our study (24 months),
only tested their study subjects for high-risk HPV at two time points,
and focused on one aspect of the natural history of high-risk HPV
(persistence or clearance) in a given study. These individual studies
were also not designed to investigate a combination of antioxidants,
Received 7/7/04; revised 9/7/04; accepted 9/28/04.
Grant support: Bristol-Myers Squibb/Mead Johnson Biomedical Research Grant
Program and Clinical Nutrition Research Unit at UAB Grant P30 DK56336.
The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page
charges. This article must therefore be hereby marked advertisement in accordance with
18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact.
Requests for reprints: Chandrika J Piyathilake, Department of Nutrition Sciences,
Division of Nutritional Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, University of Alabama at
Birmingham, 1675 University Boulevard, Webb 318A, Birmingham, AL 35294. Phone:
(205) 975-5398; Fax: (205) 966-2859; E-mail: piyathic@uab.edu.
©2004 American Association for Cancer Research.
8788