VOL. 14, NO. 19, OCTOBER 2019 ISSN 1819-6608
ARPN Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences
©2006-2019 Asian Research Publishing Network (ARPN). All rights reserved.
www.arpnjournals.com
3328
ESTIMATION OF RUNOFF FOR BINA RIVER BASIN USING CURVE
NUMBER MODEL AND GIS TECHNIQUES
Ankit Balvanshi and H. L. Tiwari
Department of Civil Engineering, Maulana Azad National Institute of Technology, Bhopal, India
E-Mail: ankit19balvanshi@rediffmail.com
ABSTRACT
Rainfall-Runoff computation of any basin plays a vital role in development of the water resources project of any
country. Looking on the industrial importance of Bina river basin situated in Central India, this basin was selected for
rainfall-runoff modeling by implementing the SCS CN conceptual model with the variation in initial abstraction ratio
value, along with the GIS tool. Runoff assessment is carried out using daily rainfall data, gauge-discharge data,
meteorological data of Bina river basin, India. A new trial was made to estimate the runoff more precisely by varying the
Initial Abstraction Ratio for the Bina river basin. The Bina catchment area of 1120 km
2
has all over hydrologic soil type C
& D, which indicates high runoff potential on ground. Results specify a initial abstraction ratio (λ) value of 0.20 gives a
better fit to the data and proved to be more precise for use in runoff calculations in comparison to λ = 0.1, 0.15 and 0.25.
The model was evaluated on the Nash-Sutcliffe Efficiency criteria and the coefficient of determination (R
2
) for the years
1997, 1998, 2003 and 2007. The model showed Nash-Sutcliffe efficiency in the range of 0.70 to 0.90 and R
2
values in the
range of 0.71 to 0.94. The Composite Curve Number came out to be 77 for the basin. It was concluded that initial
abstraction ratio λ = 0.1, 1.15 results in slight over prediction for this catchment while λ = 0.25 slightly under predicts the
runoff. This research study indicates that the SCS CN model when employed with GIS tool becomes more useful for the
hydrological study of any basin having hydrologic soil group C & D, with customary value of λ = 0.2.
Keywords: rainfall, runoff, SCS CN, GIS, initial abstraction ratio.
1. INTRODUCTION
Water is an important natural resource which
needs preservation, control and management. A rainfall
runoff model is helpful in computation of discharge from a
basin, Das [1]. Runoff is a sign of the availability of water
in any area, thus the water resources can be properly
managed by implementing and improving the engineering
practices, Zade [2]. Rainfall data, catchment area, soil
type, land use, vegetative cover and moisture content of
soil are some primary input data required for any kind of
model development, Tiwari et al. [3]. The Soil
Conservation Service Curve Number (SCS-CN) method is
widely used for predicting direct runoff volume for a given
rainfall event, Mishra et al. [4], Kumar et al. [5]. This
method was originally developed by the US Department of
Agriculture, Soil Conservation Service for application to
hydrologic design activities connected with small
agricultural watersheds, Soil Conservation Service [6].
Ever since the development of the curve number method,
it has turned out to be an extensively used method for
estimating and predicting runoff, Berod et al.[7], Kyoung
[8], Mishra et al. [4], Nagarajan et al. [9]. Sarangi [10]
employed the ED GIUH and NRCS CN approach for the
evaluation of curve numbers for ungauged catchments. It
was concluded that the ED GIUH technique was able to
estimate runoff more precisely (E = 0.96, R
2
= 0.97) if the
storm duration was less than 6 hours while the curve
number method is more suitable for rainfall events more
than 6 hours (E = 0.84, R
2
=0.89). The researchers
nowadays believe that the conventional method of data
collection is not as accurate as the RS data, so use of RS
data and GIS tool has now become a global trend,
Balvanshi and Tiwari [11]. The RS data is very useful in
the rainfall runoff modelling and modelling can be done in
remote areas also, Ramakrishnan et al. [12], Pradhan et al.
[13], Somashekar et al. [14], Dhawale [15], Viji et al.
[16]. The more accurate the curve number, the more
precise and accurate is the result of the SCS CN model,
Balvanshi and Tiwari [12], Joycee and Santhi [17], Moon
et al. [18]. Jiang [19] conducted a research study using the
CN model with the variation in initial abstraction ratio
values (0.2, 0.05). The value of 0.05 was best fitted for
watershed. The Runoff estimation using λ = 0.05 was
found better than λ= 0.2 in 252 of 307 cases. The initial
abstraction ratio (λ) is one of the crucial parameter after
the curve number in SCS CN model.
In the present research study, Bina river basin is
chosen having catchment area about 1120 km
2
. The
catchment area of Bina basin mainly has black cotton soils
with high shrinking and swelling property and classified
under hydrologic soil group C and D. This research study
also portrays the effect in efficiency of SCS CN model
with variation of values of initial abstraction ratio (λ) 0.10,
0.15, 0.20, 0.25 for the Bina river basin.
2. METHODOLOGY
A The basic data required to develop and apply
the SCS CN method is the rainfall, soil retention or soil
storage, land use pattern, soil group/type. The curve
number is actually the main driver of the SCS CN method.
The value of curve number depends on the land use/ land
cover of any catchment, NEH Section 4 Soil Conservation
Service [6]. The final SCS CN model equations for runoff
estimation used in calculation are expressed as follows:
Q=
(P−I
a
)
2
(P−I
a
)+S
if P ≥ Ia … (1)