Enthusiasm in the Development of
Radical Innovations
Birgitta Sandberg
People involved in the development of radical innovations tend to feel a lot of enthusiasm. It
has been claimed that, in fact, this enthusiasm fosters the innovativeness. The purpose of this
study is to analyse how enthusiasm is created and sustained in this process. The theoretical
framework combines the previous literature on champions and enthusiasm-creating systems.
The study analyses enthusiasm in five processes of radical innovation. The results indicate
that it is not only champions but also innovation-development teams who contribute to
spreading enthusiasm throughout organizations. Eventually, the enthusiasm also spreads
outside to the customers. Five inhibitors of enthusiasm were identified: commitment, engage-
ment, trust, results and help gaps.
Introduction
R
adical innovations are innovations that are
new both to the firm and to the market. It
has been claimed that their development is
critical to the long-term survival of many
firms, since they provide the foundation on
which future generations of products or ser-
vices are created (McDermott & O’Connor,
2002). The newness of these innovations
creates various challenges for the firms
involved. They have to cope not only with con-
siderable technological and commercial uncer-
tainties, but they also often face resistance
from inside. Individual decision makers may
find it very difficult to risk supporting a devel-
opment project that might eventually fail
because there is no market for the product
(Christensen, 1997).
Although the development of radical inno-
vations is difficult, the individuals who are
engaged in the process often feel very enthu-
siastic and stimulated. Nayak and Kettering-
ham (1986), for instance, argued that spirit and
emotion within individuals fuels the creation
of radical innovations. Hence, it is surprising
how little research attention has been given
to the enthusiasm that is prevalent in this
process.
Enthusiasm is often characterized as a
strong feeling about something (see, for
example, the definition in the Oxford Advanced
Learner’s Dictionary of Current English, 1989).
Glassman and McAfee (1990) describe it as
‘being excited or highly aroused’ or having
‘ardent zeal’ towards something. However,
Collins Cobuild English Language Dictionary
(1987) offers a more detailed definition: ‘great
eagerness to be involved in a particular activ-
ity, because it is something you like and enjoy
or that you think is important’. This definition
is used in this study, since it is more extensive
in that it encompasses not only feelings but
also action, i.e., ‘being involved’. Marcus and
Mackuen (1993) also acknowledge the behav-
ioural aspect of enthusiasm: according to
them, ‘enthusiasts throw themselves into the
cause’.
Feelings are an inherent component of
social behaviour. They are particularly likely
to influence judgements when people faced
with a complex task are in need of exten-
sive and constructive information processing.
Their role is further accentuated in situations in
which there is ambiguity and uncertainty,
when new information needs to be assimi-
lated, and when people desire to make accu-
rate judgements and good decisions (Forgas &
George, 2001). This description seems to fit
the context of radical-innovation development.
The people involved are often faced with
abundant information characterized by uncer-
tainty and ambiguity, and out of this informa-
tion they have to make decisions that chart
the course of their development project. In
other words, they are dealing with complex
ENTHUSIASM IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF RADICAL INNOVATIONS 265
Volume 16 Number 3 2007
doi:10.1111/j.1467-8691.2007.00440.x
© 2007 The Author
Journal compilation © 2007 Blackwell Publishing