Experimental validation of a geometric method for
the design of stable and broadband vibration
controllers using a propeller blade test rig
Ubaid Ubaid
*
, Steve Daley
†
, Simon Pope
*
, Ilias Zazas
†
*
Automatic Control and Systems Engineering, University of Sheffield, S1 3JD, UK.
†
Institute of Sound and Vibration Research, University of Southampton, SO17 1BJ, UK.
Abstract—A systematic geometric design methodology to gen-
erate a stable controller for simultaneous local and remote atten-
uation that was previously proposed is experimentally validated
on a structure. The local control path transfer function for this
experimental system is non-minimum phase due to which the
original broadband controller design would yield an unstable
controller. Here a modified procedure for systems with local non-
minimum phase dynamics is used to generate a stable controller.
According to this method, reduction in vibration at local and
remote points on a structure can be parameterised in terms
of the available design freedom and a controller is realised in
terms of the optimal selection of this using the minimum phase
counterpart of the local control path transfer function. The
modified method results in a controller that is both stable and
stabilizing and which achieves the desired vibration attenuation
at the local and remote points on the structure. An experimental
facility that replicates the vibration transmission through the
shaft of a propeller blade rig system is used to demonstrate the
method. Vibration for excitation near the first bending mode
frequency of the resonating part of this structure is attenuated
at the non-resonating part of the system without deteriorating
vibration at the resonating end.
I. I NTRODUCTION
Active control for reduction of vibration at a specific point
on a complex interconnected structure can potentially enhance
vibration at other points on the structure [1]. A controller
design technique to address the vibration attenuation problem
at local and remote points on a structure simultaneously using
only a single locally placed sensor actuator pair was presented
for a discrete frequency excitation case in [2] and later
extended for the broadband case [3]. For vibration attenuation
over an arbitrary frequency band, controller implementation
involves inversion of the local control path transfer function.
When the local control path transfer function is non min-
imum phase, then the controller itself would be unstable.
This problem can be solved using a new design freedom [4]
to parameterise reduction in vibration at local and remote
points whereby the controller is implemented in terms of the
minimum phase counterpart of the local control path transfer
function. Additionally, to improve robustness to unmodelled
high frequency dynamics, a filter is incorporated into the
design freedom selection [5] such that the gain of the closed
loop system rolls off at high frequency without deteriorating
controller performance in the excitation frequency bandwidth.
The aim of this paper is to present experimental verification of
this design technique for attenuation of vibration at both local
and remote points on a blade rig simultaneously. Trade-offs
between stability robustness and disturbance attenuation are
also highlighted in terms of the values of the design freedom
parameter.
II. EXPERIMENTAL SET- UP
A schematic diagram of the blade rig is shown in figure
1. The primary excitation signal f
p
(t) is a common signal
fed to the two smaller shakers attached at both ends of the
bar which acts as the transient loading force due to rotation
of the propeller blades. The vibration at the blade end of
the shaft q
p
(t) is the summation of outputs measured by
two accelerometers connected near each of the disturbance
shakers. The control input f
c
(t) is applied to the control
shaker attached at the other end of propeller shaft on the
thrust block and a local accelerometer on the thrust block
measures local vibration levels q
c
(t). Vibration is transmitted
from the blade end along the shaft to the thrust block end and
is particularly detrimental at the blade resonant frequency. Due
to difficulties in measuring and actuating at the blade end for
most applications, it is desired to control both blade vibration
and its transmission using sensors and actuators placed at the
thrust block only
1
. This blade system can be considered as a
two input two output system with the transfer function matrix
relating the disturbance and control inputs to the remote and
local vibration outputs as
q
c
(jω)
q
p
(jω)
=
g
cc
(jω) g
cp
(jω)
g
pc
(jω) g
pp
(jω)
f
c
(jω)
f
p
(jω)
(1)
In the next section, a design freedom parameter is introduced
which parameterizes reduction in vibration at the thrust block
and blade end. A controller implemented in terms of the
optimally selected values of this design freedom would achieve
the targeted vibration reduction.
III. GENERAL ALGORITHM
The detailed synthesis of a stable controller using the geo-
metric approach is given in [4], [5]. For the system described
in (1), the aim is to design a feedback controller k(jω) using as
feedback signal only from the thrust block to achieve vibration
1
Note that this general concept is the subject of several BAE Systems
patents
369
UKACC International Conference on Control 2012
Cardiff, UK, 3-5 September 2012
978-1-4673-1558-6/12/$31.00 ©2012 IEEE