224 JONA • Vol. 33, No. 4 • April 2003
JONA
Volume 33, Number 4, pp 224–234
©2003, Lippincott Williams & Wilkins, Inc.
DFN
Objective: To test a causal model of the impact of (a)
nursing unit context on professional nursing prac-
tice; (b) professional practice on selected organiza-
tional (nurses’ work satisfaction, nursing turnover,
average length of patient stay) and patient outcomes
(patient satisfaction, rate of reported medication er-
rors, and falls); and (c) nursing unit context on these
same organizational and patient outcomes.
Summary Background Data: Professional nursing
practice has been linked to positive outcomes for
both nurses and patients. In contrast to other stud-
ies, this study focuses on professional nursing prac-
tice specifically at the nursing unit level, and uses a
new analytic technique that permits examination of
the simultaneous effects of professional nursing
practice on both organizational and patient out-
comes.
Methods: Data were collected from 1682 registered
nurses, and 1326 patients on 124 general medical-
surgical nursing units in 64 general short-term acute
care hospitals in the southeast. Multilevel structural
equation modeling was used to analyze the data.
Results: We found that professional nursing practice
had consistent effects across model levels on nurs-
ing satisfaction, but very limited effects on other out-
comes. Important differences in the hospital- and
nursing unit level models support continued use of
multilevel modeling techniques in the study of orga-
nizational and patient outcomes.
There is an accumulating body of evidence suggest-
ing that “professional nursing practice”—defined as
“a system that supports registered nurse control
over the delivery of nursing care and the environ-
ment in which care is delivered”
1, p 354
—contributes
to improved outcomes for the organization and its
patients.
2
Professional nursing practice is character-
ized by decentralization of nurses’ clinical decision-
making, enhanced autonomy, and collaborative rela-
tionships with physicians. For example, Havens and
Aiken
3
report that nurses’ job satisfaction is signifi-
cantly higher,
4-6
and patient mortality significantly
lower,
7
in hospitals enacting professional nursing
practice. Lower mortality on dedicated AIDS units
that promote professional nursing practice has also
been documented.
8
In addition, less emotional ex-
haustion, safer work environments,
9
and lower rates
of needlestick injuries
10
have been reported in hos-
pitals engaging in professional nursing practice.
However,most research in this area has focused
either on the individual nurse, and relies predomi-
nantly on primary data, or on the hospital, and relies
on secondary data.Yet, it is likely that variability in
nursing unit organization can best be seen, and the
relationship of nursing unit organization to out-
comes understood most clearly, at the nursing unit
level. Second, since organizations produce multiple,
concurrent outcomes, it is important to use an ana-
lytic technique that permits investigation of several
outcomes simultaneously. Finally, because a nursing
unit’s behavior is partly determined by the hospital
in which it is located, a multilevel perspective allows
examination of this important interplay.
To address these issues, in the Outcomes Re-
search in Nursing Administration Project (ORNA),
we used a long-established theoretical framework,
focused on the nursing unit as the focal unit of analy-
sis, and used multilevel structural equation modeling
Professional Nursing Practice
Impact on Organizational and Patient Outcomes
Barbara A. Mark, PhD, RN, FAAN
Jeanne Salyer, PhD, RN
Thomas T.H. Wan, PhD
Authors’ affiliations: The University of North Carolina at
Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC (Dr Mark); Virginia Commonwealth
University,Richmond,Va (Drs Salyer and Wan).
Corresponding author: Barbara A. Mark, PhD, RN, FAAN, Sarah
Frances Russell Distinguished Professor,The University of North
Carolina at Chapel Hill, School of Nursing, Carrington Hall
CB#7460, Chapel Hill, NC 27599-7460 (b_mark@unc.edu).