Journal of Radioanalytical and Nuclear Chemistry, Vol. 271, No.2 (2007) 345–351
0236–5731/USD 20.00 Akadémiai Kiadó, Budapest
© 2007 Akadémiai Kiadó, Budapest Springer, Dordrecht
INAA with Compton suppression: How much can the analysis
of plant materials be improved?
M. A. Bacchi,
1
* L. G. C. Santos,
1
E. A. De Nadai Fernandes,
1
P. Bode,
2
F. S. Tagliaferro,
1
E. J. França
1
1
Centro de Energia Nuclear na Agricultura, Universidade de São Paulo, Caixa Postal 96, 13400-970 Piracicaba, Brazil
2
Interfaculty Reactor Institute, Delft University of Technology, Mekelweg 15, 2629 JB Delft, The Netherlands
(Received April 13, 2006)
The effectiveness of a Compton suppression system (CSS) for instrumental neutron activation analysis of plant materials was evaluated.
Suppression factors were measured with
137
Cs sources. Five certified reference materials were analyzed and the detection limits calculated from
both suppressed and unsuppressed spectra were compared. The CSS demonstrated to be useful for lowering the detection limits of ten out of
sixteen elements tested, showing a maximum improvement factor of 3.9. The system performance was strongly influenced by the sample
composition and also by the measurement conditions, indicating the importance of testing each individual sample type and analytical protocol.
Introduction
Instrumental neutron activation analysis (INAA) is
known for being nearly independent on effects arising
from the sample matrix. However, the sample
composition still has some influence on the analytical
results, since the degree of accuracy can be affected by
interfering reactions or spectral interferences.
Furthermore, the sample composition can also lead to
acquisition of γ-ray spectra with peaks on a high
background, increasing the uncertainty of peak areas and
causing negative impact on the precision of results and
on the detection limits. The Compton scattering of γ-rays
in the detector is often the most important source of the
background under low energy γ-ray peaks if measuring
in the presence of high energy γ-rays. For such a case,
the use of anti-Compton techniques can significantly
reduce the background, improve the detection limits and
also lower the measurement uncertainty.
The performance of a Compton suppression system
(CSS) is usually characterized by means of suppression
factors determined from spectra of either
137
Cs or
60
Co
sources. The suppression factor is defined as the ratio of
the peak-to-Compton ratios for suppressed and
unsuppressed spectra. The effectiveness of a CSS in
reducing the γ-ray spectrum background depends first of
all on the equipment configuration itself and on the
radionuclide being measured. Nevertheless, the source–
detector arrangement and the source composition, i.e.,
the presence of other radionuclides, are also factors
affecting the effectiveness of the equipment for a
specific measurement. Consequently, it is difficult to
estimate the improvement obtained for the determination
of specific elements in a real sample, if only the
suppression factor for single radionuclide sources is
measured.
* E-mail: mabacchi@cena.usp.br
Since the first developments of anti-Compton
techniques in the late 1960's, the use of CSS in INAA
has being considered. Although COOPER and
BROWNELL
1
explored the applicability of CSS for
activation analysis early in 1967, most publications are
from two decades later, when dedicated systems were
described
2,3
and some applications were investigated.
4,5
In 1994, LANDSBERGER
6
published an overview about
the use of anti-Compton techniques in INAA for
environmental samples.
With exceptions,
7
publications about Compton
suppression INAA applied to biological materials have
been focused on the determination of one or a few
elements. Moreover, the anti-Compton techniques have
been often used
8–10
in combination with epithermal
neutron flux for improving the determination of
elements like As, Cd, Cu, I and Sb in the presence of
high amounts of Br, Cl and Na. Considering such a
scenario, there is still a need for studies evaluating the
analysis of different matrices by Compton suppression
INAA with thermal neutrons, in order to further explore
its multi-element characteristics.
Here, the usefulness of a CSS for the determination
of sixteen elements in plant materials was assessed. Five
certified reference materials were analyzed by INAA
using different measurement conditions and the
detection limits calculated from both suppressed and
unsuppressed spectra were compared.
Experimental
Description of the Compton suppression system
The CSS was integrated by Ortec and consists of a
main HPGe detector surrounded by two secondary
detectors as to provide a near 4π configuration (Fig. 1).