Reduction of Calcification of Carbodiimide-Processed
Heart Valve Tissue by Prior Blocking of Amine Groups
with Monoaldehydes
Frank Everaerts
1
, Mirian Gillissen
1
, Mark Torrianni
1
, Peter Zilla
2
, Paul Human
2
, Marc
Hendriks
1
, Jan Feijen
3
1
Medtronic Inc., Minneapolis, USA,
2
UCT Cardiovascular Research, University of Cape Town, South Africa,
3
Faculty of
Science and Engineering, University of Twente, The Netherlands
Calcification of bioprostheses after implantation is a
commonly occurring phenomenon that may have sev-
eral different causative factors. In order to mitigate the
local inflammatory responses and associated enzymat-
ic degradation that begins after implantation of the bio-
prosthesis, the tissue matrix is usually preserved,
primarily by the introduction of cross-links between
the collagen molecules in the matrix. Glutaraldehyde
(GA)-based cross-linking of valvular bioprostheses is
the current standard (1), and these prostheses have a
low incidence of thromboembolism and a satisfactory
hemodynamic performance. Nevertheless, problems of
durability have been reported with this process (2-5).
Clinical failure due to cuspal calcification has been reg-
istered in many cases (4), with calcium deposition caus-
ing valve stiffness, tearing and rupture that result in
stenosis and/or insufficiency (6). The exact mechanism
of calcification is still not well understood, and numer-
ous hypotheses have been described in the literature.
Most theories are based on the loss of components from
the matrix, such as proteoglycans and glycosaminogly-
cans during the reaction with GA (7). These compo-
nents act as natural inhibitors of calcification. Other
factors mentioned are changes in the morphology and
charge distribution in the valve after fixation, and the
occurrence of local stress in the valve material (2-4,8).
In various studies, post-GA fixation reactions were
developed with the aim of reducing calcification, and
some of these were successfully introduced into clini-
cal practice (9). During the past few years, research has
also focused on the use of alternative cross-linking
agents (1). Cross-linking based on water-soluble car-
bodiimide (EDC) in the presence of N-hydroxysuccin-
imide (NHS) has been reported to be a particularly
promising alternative to GA (10-12). Calcification after
explantation has been reported to be less than that
Presented in part at the Second Biennial Meeting of the Society for
Heart Valve Disease, 28th June-1st July 2003, Palais des Congrès,
Paris, France
Address for correspondence:
Frank Everaerts, Medtronic Bakken Research Center,
Endepolsdomein 5, 6229 GW Maastricht, The Netherlands
e-mail: Frank.Everaerts@medtronic.com
© Copyright by ICR Publishers 2006
Background and aim of the study: Failure of implant-
ed bioprostheses due to calcification is a commonly
occurring phenomenon. In order to prevent calcifica-
tion, many alternative cross-linking methods to glu-
taraldehyde (GA) have been developed and
evaluated.
Methods: In a novel approach an improved carbodi-
imide (EDC) cross-linking method that comprises a
two-step process was developed. First, the available
amine groups in (tissue) collagen were blocked with
a monoaldehyde, followed by an EDC-activated
cross-linking reaction of the carboxyl groups in the
tissue with a poly(propylene glycol) bis 2-(amino-
propyl) ether (Jeffamine™).
Results: Samples processed via this method have
shown a significantly reduced calcification in a sub-
dermal juvenile rat model compared to samples with
standard GA treatment. In the present study, heart
valve tissue was blocked with various monoalde-
hydes, followed by reaction with Jeffamine using
carbodiimide cross-linking chemistry. Leaflet calcifi-
cation was almost eliminated using different alde-
hydes, whereas wall calcification was maximally 95%
reduced when propionaldehyde was used as block-
ing agent, as compared to a carbodiimide cross-
linked control without Jeffamine and blocked amine
groups.
Conclusion: Amine blocking and cross-linking tech-
nology appears promising in the design of the next
generation of tissue valves. Calcification was signifi-
cantly reduced compared to GA cross-linking. The
mechanistic insight of decreased wall calcification is
still unknown, and research investigations are ongo-
ing.
The Journal of Heart Valve Disease 2006;15:269-277