Appl Phys A
DOI 10.1007/s00339-011-6702-8
Numerical simulation of process dynamics during laser beam
drilling with short pulses
Karl-Heinz Leitz · Holger Koch · Andreas Otto ·
Michael Schmidt
Received: 26 October 2011 / Accepted: 15 November 2011
© Springer-Verlag 2011
Abstract In the last years, laser beam drilling became in-
creasingly important for many technical applications as it
allows the contactless production of high quality drill holes.
So far, mainly short laser pulses are of industrial relevance,
as they offer a good compromise between precision and ef-
ficiency and combine high ablation efficiency with low ther-
mal damage of the workpiece. Laser beam drilling in this
pulse length range is still a highly thermal process. There are
two ablation mechanisms: evaporation and melt expulsion.
In order to achieve high quality processing results, a basic
process understanding is absolutely necessary. Yet, process
observations in laser beam drilling suffer from both the short
time scales and the restricted accessibility of the interaction
zone. Numerical simulations offer the possibility to acquire
additional knowledge of the process as they allow a direct
look into the drill hole during the ablation process. In this
contribution, a numerical finite volume multi-phase simu-
lation model for laser beam drilling with short laser pulses
shall be presented. The model is applied for a basic study of
the ablation process with μs and ns laser pulses. The ob-
tained results show good qualitative correspondence with
experimental data.
K.-H. Leitz ( ) · H. Koch · M. Schmidt
Chair of Photonic Technologies and Erlangen Graduate School in
Advanced Optical Technologies (SAOT), University of
Erlangen–Nuremberg, Paul-Gordan-Str. 3, 91052 Erlangen,
Germany
e-mail: karl-heinz.leitz@lpt.uni-erlangen.de
A. Otto
Institute for Production Engineering and Laser Technology,
Vienna University of Technology, Gusshausstrasse 30,
1040 Vienna, Austria
1 Introduction
Generally, the quality of laser drilled holes gets better with
shorter pulse length, mainly due to the reduced formation
of melt. However, efficiency decreases as well (see Fig. 1).
Single pulse drilling using ms and μs pulses allows the pro-
duction of many holes within a short time. As there is quite
a big amount of melt involved in the process, the quality
and reproducibility of the holes is rather low. If higher pre-
cision is needed, short and ultrashort pulses in combination
with adequate drilling strategies are applied. In this pulse
length range, only a small amount of melt is involved in the
process, which means that high accuracy can be achieved.
However, in the past the medium laser powers of ultrashort-
pulsed systems were not sufficient to fulfil industrial effi-
ciency requirements. Besides, studies have shown that even
with ultrashort pulses the generation of melt cannot be pre-
vented completely [1–7]. Only recently first attempts for the
application of ultrashort laser pulses in industrial produc-
tion have been reported [8, 9]. However, so far in many in-
dustrial applications Q-switched laser systems in the micro-
and nanosecond range are still widely common because they
can deliver high medium laser power and allow a good com-
promise between precision and efficiency. As in these pro-
cesses, there is still a certain amount of melt involved, the
choice of the right process parameters and the most suitable
drilling strategy is of extreme importance in order to achieve
the requested quality [10].
When a laser pulse hits the material, within a short time
a multitude of highly dynamic coupled physical processes
take place (see Fig. 2). The laser beam is absorbed on the
surface of the material, and due to the high intensities of
pulsed laser radiation, nearly instantly surface temperatures
of some thousand Kelvin are reached, leading to an abrupt
evaporation, ionisation of the material and the occurrence of