ROLE OF ADVANCED 2 AND 3-DIMENSIONAL ULTRASOUND FOR
DETECTING PROSTATE CANCER
K. C. BALAJI, WILLIAM R. FAIR, ERNEST J. FELEPPA, CHRISTOPHER R. PORTER,
HAROLD TSAI, TIAN LIU, ANDREW KALISZ, STELLA URBAN AND JOHN GILLESPIE
From the University of Nebraska Medical Center, Omaha, Nebraska, Haelth, Riverside Research Institute and New York Presbyterian
Medical Center, New York and State University of New York Medical Center, Stony Brook, New York, New York, Kaiser-Permanente, Los
Angeles, California, and National Cancer Institute, Bethesda, Maryland
ABSTRACT
Purpose: We explored the clinical usefulness of spectrum analysis and neural networks for
classifying prostate tissue and identifying prostate cancer in patients undergoing transrectal
ultrasound for diagnostic or therapeutic reasons.
Materials and Methods: Data on a cohort of 215 patients who underwent transrectal ultra-
sound guided prostate biopsies at Memorial-Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, New York, New
York were included in this study. Radio frequency data necessary for 2 and 3-dimensional (D)
computer reconstruction of the prostate were digitally recorded at transrectal ultrasound and
prostate biopsy. The data were spectrally processed and 2-D tissue typing images were generated
based on a pre-trained neural network classification. We used manually masked 2-D tissue
images as building blocks for generating 3-D tissue images and the images were tissue type color
coded using custom software. Radio frequency data on the study cohort were analyzed for cancer
probability using the data set pre-trained by neural network methods and compared with
conventional B-mode imaging. ROC curves were generated for the 2 methods using biopsy results
as the gold standard.
Results: The mean area under the ROC curve plus or minus SEM for detecting prostate cancer
for the conventional B-mode and neural network methods was 0.66 0.03 and 0.80 0.05,
respectively. Sensitivity and specificity for detecting prostate cancer by the neural network
method were significantly increased compared with conventional B-mode imaging. In addition,
the 2 and 3-D prostate images provided excellent visual identification of areas with a higher
likelihood of cancer.
Conclusions: Spectrum analysis could significantly improve the detection and evaluation of
prostate cancer. Routine real-time application of spectrum analysis may significantly decrease
the number of false-negative biopsies and improve the detection of prostate cancer at transrectal
ultrasound guided prostate biopsy. It may also provide improved identification of prostate cancer
foci during therapeutic intervention, such as brachytherapy, external beam radiotherapy or
cryotherapy. In addition, 2 and 3-D images with prostate cancer foci specifically identified can
help surgical planning and may in the distant future be an additional reliable noninvasive
method of selecting patients for prostate biopsy.
KEY WORDS: prostate; prostatic neoplasms; imaging, three-dimensional; ultrasonography; spectrum analysis
Transrectal ultrasound guided prostatic biopsy is currently
the standard for detecting prostate cancer in the United
States. In a study of 132,246 men undergoing prostate biopsy
for the first time 38.2% were diagnosed with prostate cancer.
Repeat biopsy within a year in 6,350 of the remaining men
revealed prostate cancer in 25.2%, suggesting a significant
false-negative rate of more than 40% at initial biopsy.
1
The
reported sensitivity, specificity and positive predictive values
of hypoechoic lesions of the prostate on transrectal ultra-
sound, which are considered characteristic of prostate cancer,
are only 85.5%, 28.4% and 29%, respectively, for diagnosing
prostate cancer.
2
Recently considerable advances have been
made in medical ultrasonography, including transducer tech-
nology, color Doppler imaging, echo contrast, ultrasonic tem-
perature sensing and high intensity focused ultrasound.
3, 4
Furthermore, using echo contrast with power Doppler tech-
nology in patients with suspected prostate cancer improves
the sensitivity of detecting prostate cancer by about 50%,
while maintaining 80% specificity.
5
In the last 2 decades computational technology has been
increasingly used in medicine and neural networks are cur-
rently being investigated for clinical use in urology.
6
Because
conventional B-mode ultrasound has limited capability for
detecting prostate cancer, we investigated the combined use-
fulness of spectrum analysis of radio frequency data acquired
during transrectal ultrasound of the prostate and neural
network methods for improving prostate cancer detection.
We investigated whether classification based on spectrum
analysis parameters by neural network methods provide bet-
ter sensitivity and specificity than conventional B-mode im-
aging. In addition, we constructed 2 and 3-dimensional (D)
images of the prostate using color codes to indicate cancer
likelihood, which in the future may prove invaluable for
real-time imaging of prostate cancer during transrectal ul-
trasound for diagnostic or therapeutic purposes.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Transrectal ultrasound guided prostate biopsy. The cohort of
215 patients in this study underwent biopsy for abnormal pros-
Accepted for publication July 5, 2002.
Supported by National Institutes of Health Grant CA53561.
0022-5347/02/1686-2422/0 Vol. 168, 2422–2425, December 2002
THE JOURNAL OF UROLOGY
®
Printed in U.S.A.
Copyright © 2002 by AMERICAN UROLOGICAL ASSOCIATION,INC.
®
DOI: 10.1097/01.ju.0000036435.13421.57
2422