JOURNAL OF SUSTAINABLE ENERGY VOL. 5, NO. 3, SEPTEMBER, 2014
ISSN 2067-5534 © 2014 JSE
ANALYSIS ON THE ENERGY PERFORMANCES OF OTL
TRAMS
FELEA I.*, CSUZI IS.**, DAN F.*, CHIREA V.*
*
University of Oradea, University Street, No. 1, Oradea
**
Oradea Public Transport Company, (OTL S.A.)
ifelea@uoradea.ro
Abstract - This paper summarizes the results obtained
from measurements carried out on trams operated
with DC motors at the request of Oradea Transport
Company (OTL). It aims on achieving a comparative
analysis electrically driven trams (EDT) with d.c.
motors (DCM), in terms of energy performance, based
on a defined synthetic indicator and evaluated in the
paper. The paper is structured in four parts. After
presenting the importance of this analysis, through the
significant use of electric energy (EE) in urban public
transport and a brief description of the system under
analysis, the second part of the paper presents the
workings and results with respect to 21 pieces of EDT-
DCM.
Comparative interpretation of the results and
conclusions of the analysis are contained in Part three
of the paper and in the last part is specified the need
and how to further research this area.
Keywords: trams, energy performance, power auditing.
1. INTRODUCTION
Sustainable development is one of the dominant
themes of globalisation. Transport and energy are two key
challenges in the sustainable development strategy of the
EU [1]. It is known that at the EU level, the power
consumption in systems of transport is of about 30 % of
all consumption, greenhouse gas emissions caused by the
means of transport being as [2]. Therefore, it is clear that
environmental concerns with regards to reduce energy
consumption in the transport systems are very important
and entered the main concerns to increase the social,
economic and environmental performance of these
systems [3,4].
Operating concept and targets on the sustainable
development, for energy-intensive processes, including
those of transport, results through the reduction of fossil
fuel consumption in two ways:
a) increasing the efficiency of energy processes;
b) increasing the use of renewable energy sources.
Targets and pathways to the action of the European
Union are very clearly defined and regulated [5, 6] aimed
essentially to the reduction by 2020 of the energy
consumption from fossil fuels by 20% and increase the
share of renewable sources by 20%.
In Romania, energy efficiency is much lower than in
other countries with top-of-the-line technology. Still,
many processes and technology services exist. In
Romania, these take place with energy intensity of [2 ÷ 3]
times greater than similar processes modernised in the
"flagship" countries under technological aspect. In the last
period, legislative and financial efforts are made [7,8] for
the alignment of the Romanian status to European
standards, not only by the appearance of energy efficiency
but also under the aspect of renewable resource usage.
From perspective of sustainable development, it is
essential that local official have to pay attention to:
• Development takes priority over urban public
transport (UPT), which will reduce auto traffic
with all the implications;
• Development of electrified UPT, transport system
which is much cleaner, is relatively quiet and
enhanced safety in circulation.
Specific problems of urban public transport systems
are reflected in literature on the subject. A significant part
of work aims the performance of UPT systems,
performance quantified by: efficiency, quality of service,
impact to the environment. In [4,9] one identified factor
which influence the application of the UPT with a
particular focus, specially, on the quality service, and in
[10] one proposed and exemplified a methodology
applied in the preparation of studies of quality of the UPT
system. Detailed methodology for the assessment of
quality of the service of transport shall be made in
[11,12], out using the deciding factors of impact such as:
availability, comfort, and convenience. Availability of the
transmission system is examined in terms of frequency of
the service zone and service coverage. For a system of
UPT with buses shall be analysed comfort and
convenience. Effectiveness of concrete UPT systems is
analysed for example in [12,13,14]. The authors work
[12] analysed, compared, UPT with buses and
trolleybuses, assuming that the variance of the UPT is a
complex problem, dependent on many economical,
technical and eco-friendly factors. Performed analysis
show that the containing values obtained for the two
variants, include specific consumption of energy, and are
very close. Thus, in [13] one shall assess the effectiveness
of the UPT systems of 12 cities in Europe and 7 in Brazil.
On the basis of results obtained, the authors get to the
conclusion that, in nine cities in Europe, and in one of
Brazil UPT is effective; the inefficiency is due to social
interferences. The energy efficiency of UPT with electric
traction is presented in [14]. It aims at determining energy
efficiency for locomotives and its impact to the
optimization of the running lines parameters, the
modernisation of the stations and optimal management of
traffic.