Received: 6 December 2018 Revised: 22 December 2018 Accepted: 23 December 2018
DOI: 10.1002/sscp.201800144
RESEARCH ARTICLE
Variability of temperature dependences of the retention of
strongly polar compounds under ZIC-HILIC liquid
chromatographic mechanism
Maria Tanase
1
Elena Bacalum
2
Victor David
1
1
University of Bucharest, Faculty of
Chemistry, Department of Analytical
Chemistry, Bucharest, Romania
2
Research Institute - ICUB, Blvd. M.
Kogalniceanu, University of Bucharest,
Bucharest, Romania
Correspondence
Dr. Victor David, University of Bucharest,
Faculty of Chemistry, Department of
Analytical Chemistry, Sos. Panduri, no 90,
Bucharest 050663, Romania.
Email: victor.david@chimie.unibuc.ro
The retentions of 13 strongly polar compounds (aminocids; dipeptides, drugs, and
other biologically active species) were studied for two SeQuant ZIC-HILIC (Merck)
stationary phases containing a zwitterionic sulfobetaine moiety covalently attached
to porous silica (3.5 and 5 μm particle size). Methanol and acetonitrile were used
as organic components in the mobile phase composition, whose aqueous phase con-
sisted in buffers of various controled pH values based on acetate-acetic acid. This
study shows various dependences of the retention on the absolute column temper-
ature, some being obeyed to van't Hoff dependence, while others not following this
rule. The values of standard enthalpy for the transfer of the analyte from mobile phase
to the stationary phase were calculated from linear van't Hoff plots, which were below
10 kJ/mol. From the polynomial regression applied to the experimental retention data
that not obeyed to a linear fit, the value of absolute temperature was calculated that
corresponds to a maximum retention for studied compounds.
KEYWORDS
non-linear plots, temperature influence, van't Hoff plots, zIC-HILIC mechanism, zwitterions
1 INTRODUCTION
Hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC),
which is typically based on a hydrophilic stationary phase
and used for separating very polar compounds, represents an
alternative HPLC to the reversed-phase LC [1,2]. Retention
of polar analytes on HILIC stationary phase depends on
the intesity of polar interactions between polar groups of
analytes and polar moieties from stationary phase [3,4]. At
their turn, these interactions depend on the composition
of the mobile phase and temperature [5–9]. Zwitterionc
liquid chromatography (ZIC-HILIC) is a particular HILIC
mechanism in liquid chromatography that uses a stationary
phase containing both anionic and cationic groups in their
structure, such as embedded quaternary amine and sulfonic
or carboxyl terminal groups [10,11]. A major role in this
mechanism is also played by the water layer adsorbed onto
the surface of the stationary phase, for which a partition
model has been proposed to explain the retention of polar
analytes [3].
Temperature may influence the retention of the analytes
separated by HILIC and the chromatographic performances,
mainly the peak shape and separation selectivity [9,12,13].
The dependence of retention on the column temperature
is generally represented by the linear van't Hoff function
between the natural logarithm of the retention factor (ln k)
and the inverse value of absolute temperature of the studied
column (1/T) [14–17]:
ln =-
Δ
0
⋅
+
Δ
0
+ ln φ (1)
In eq. (1), ΔH
0
is the standard enthalpy for the transfer of
the analyte from mobile phase to the stationary phase, ΔS
0
is standard entropy for the same partition process, R is the
universal gas constant (8.314 J K
-1
mol
-1
), T is the absolute
column temperature (namely t + 273.15, t being column tem-
perature in Celsius degree) and ϕ represents the phase volume
ratio (the volume of stationary phase to that of the mobile
phase). According to this equation the dependence between
ln k and 1/T should be linear, but in several circumstances a
12 © 2019 WILEY-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim Sep Sci plus 2019;2:12–17. www.sscp-journal.com