Electrical modeling of nanostructured thin films
A. Santabarbara, S. Spadaro, G. Conte ⁎
Electronic Engineering Department, University Roma Tre, Via della Vasca Navale, 84-00146 Rome, Italy
abstract article info
Available online 1 February 2011
Keywords:
Impedance spectroscopy
Degenerate networks
Matrices transformations
Nanocrystalline diamond
Electric circuit networks based on lumped components and distributed impedance elements are considered in
the analysis of impedance spectroscopy data of nano-structured materials. A procedure based on
transformation among degenerate networks is used as synthesis of linear, passive, one-port electric schemes
and non-distinguishable distributed elements due to the noise level in observed data. Experimental results
obtained on nitrogen doped ultra-nanocrystalline-diamond thin films are used to illustrate this process.
© 2011 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
There are electric circuit involving three or more lumped elements
and non-linear frequency dependent components that can be rear-
ranged in various ways and still yield exactly the same impedance as a
function of frequency. Obviously, for the different interconnections
the values of the elements will have to be different to yield the same
impedance spectrum. Electric circuits with lumped linear and non-
linear components are today widely used to analyze the ac response of
solid state devices [1] and impedance spectra of nano-structured
materials [2–5]. Data analysis by fitting a trial mathematical model
of an electric scheme is commonly used due to the existence of
commercial software for the analysis of impedance spectra. Frequent-
ly, parameters like χ
2
are optimized by using electric schemes with
poor or none correspondence to the physical system under study. A
problem arises when we try to transform such optimized schemes,
and related component values, with an electric scheme more adhering
to the physical system under study.
The possibility to transform a linear passive electric circuit in an
equivalent scheme was initially stated by W. Cauer [6]. He empha-
sized as electrical networks formed a group with the impedance
function as an absolute invariant and that it was possible to proceed in
a continuous manner from one network to its equivalent network by a
linear transformation of the instantaneous mesh currents and charges
of the network. The theory of the affine transformations stated by
Cauer was successively analyzed by N. Howitt [7]. He point-out as in
Cauer's work was already addressed the possibility to represent the
impedance function of a n-mesh network by a linear combination of
quadratic forms, positive and definite. The quadratic forms corre-
sponding to the rate of dissipation of energy in heat, stored electro-
magnetic and electrostatic energies. This linear combination can also
be written as a n×n matrix or decomposed in three different n×n
matrices by using the superposition principle. Successively, was
demonstrated the possibility of simultaneously subject the triple of
quadratic forms to a group of real affine transformations, leading to
equivalent passive electric circuits. Tables of such degenerate elec-
trical networks for use in the equivalent circuit analysis were reported
by S. Fletcher [8].
Observed data fitting with the mathematical model of an electric
circuit containing one or more non-linear frequency-dependent
components (CPEs) is frequently encountered in impedance spectra
analysis. CPEs have been used to describe the power-law dependence
of the impedance components on frequency widely observed in many
materials and well known as Jonscher Law [9], carriers hopping among
defective sites [10] and distribution of charge carriers paths as a
consequence of a distribution in the grains dimension [11]. As a CPE is
a non-linear component, an affine linear transformation involving
such element cannot be in principle used. The possibility to identify an
electric circuit among different equivalent networks containing CPEs
has been studied by F. Berthier et al. [12]. They conclude that in the
case of noisy impedance spectral data, CPEs contained in equivalent
schemes cannot be distinguished. In other words, the n-exponent in
the expression of CPE impedance: Z
CPE
= 1/Qs
n
remains constant,
while Q-value changes, being s the Laplace variable.
2. Material and methods
UNCD thin films were grown on p-type silicon by microwave
plasma CVD technique at 800 °C starting from a methane–argon
mixture with 5% nitrogen (see for details [13]). The thickness of the
sample was 1.5 μm. 200 nm of Silver were deposited on the UNCD film
through a shadow mask to carry out planar measurements. Measure-
ments were performed under vacuum into an APD 202 S helium gas
exchange cryostat, equipped with an Oxford ITC4 controller, in the
range 115–300 K with an accuracy of ± 1 K. Small amplitude ac signal
response was analyzed as a function of temperature employing a
Thin Solid Films 519 (2011) 4018–4021
⁎ Corresponding author.
E-mail address: gconte@uniroma3.it (G. Conte).
0040-6090/$ – see front matter © 2011 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.tsf.2011.01.195
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Thin Solid Films
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/tsf