International Journal of Mechanical & Mechatronics Engineering IJMME-IJENS Vol:19 No:03 10
190903-2727-IJMME-IJENS © June 2019 IJENS
I J E N S
Study of the Aerodynamic Structure in an
Indoor Environment Occupied by a Human
Body
Hasna Abid*
, 1,2
, Zied Driss
1
, Jamel Bessrour
2
1
Laboratory of Electro-Mechanic Systems (LASEM), National School of Engineers of Sfax (ENIS), University
of Sfax, B.P. 1173, km 3.5 Road Soukra, 3038 Sfax, TUNISIA
2
National School of Engineers of Tunis (ENIT), University of Tunis El manar, BP 37, le Belvedere, 1002 Tunis,
TUNISIA
Corresponding authors:
E-mail address:
* abidhasna@ymail.com (HasnaAbid)
Abstract-- This paper presents the CFD study of the
aerodynamic structure in an indoor environment occupied
by a human body. Reynolds Averaged Navier-Stokes
equations were used and different turbulence models were
evaluated such as the RNG k-ε turbulence model, the
standard k-ε turbulence model, the standard k-ω turbulence
model and the SST k-ω turbulence model. The results of our
simulations developed using the software ''ANSYS Fluent
17.0'' were compared with findings from anterior
experimental measurements. This comparison affirms that
the turbulence model has a direct effect on the aerodynamic
structure in an indoor environment. In fact, the SST k-ω
turbulence model presents a good agreement with the
anterior study and it is recommended for the related type of
application. These numerical results highlight a thermal
plume above the human body due to the convection heat
transfer. Finally, indoor thermal comfort analyses are
conducted at varying supply velocity
1. INTRODUCTION
The indoor environment has a huge impact on the health
of the occupant and the quality of the air [1-2]. In this
context, several studies have been conducted to study the
airflow and the temperature distribution inside buildings.
In fact, research work is divided into two main categories.
The first category is interested in the experimental study.
However, the second type of research is focused on the
validation of these results through the numerical method.
In this respect, the occupant shape is one of the
investigated parameters in the experimental analysis as
shown in the relevant experience done by Brohus et al.
[3]. They examined the flow of air around three simple
heaters: a solid rectangular torso, a rectangular torso with
a leg, a rectangular torso with a box head. Munds [4] used
a heated cylinder. Then, Bjorn et al. [5] used a thermal
mannequin. Over the past few years, Computational Fluid
Dynamics (CFD) has been widely used to study indoor
problems as this alternative is less costly. Hence, several
CFD application studied the indoor air behavior in the
indoor environment [6-10]. A number of simulations were
conducted by Deevy [11] in order to evaluate the human
body geometry effect. It is observed that the results were
not adequate next to the body for the simple geometry. In
addition, numerical analyzes were carried out with
different occupant position. On one hand, the researches
focused on the seated human body.Sorensen et al. [12]
represented a numerical study of the flow around a seated
mannequin inside a room with a displacement ventilation
system. The heat transfer was taken place by convection
and radiation. On the other hand, several researchers
assessed the airflow around a standing occupant.
Murakami et al. [13] investigated the airflow around a
standing person by a low-Reynolds number k–ε model
taking into account the thermal radiation effects. Indeed, it
is worth mentioning that CFD results are very sensitive to
the boundary conditions, computing grid qualities and the
choice of turbulence models [14]. In this context, Sideroff
and Dang [15] studied the grid resolution effect. In
addition, they applied the ν
2
- f model and the
Smagorinsky dynamic model (DSM). As a result, they
found that the DSM did not offer an advantage compared
to ν
2
– f model. Deevy et al. [16] investigated the
influence of the turbulence model to compare between a
detached-eddy simulation (DES) and an Unsteady
Reynolds-averaged approach (URANS). They noticed that
the DES model showed the best results in terms of
temperature and velocity distributions. Taghinia et al. [17]
applied the dynamic Smagorinsky model (DSM), the
SST-SAS model and the RAST (Rahman–Agarwal–
Siikonen–Taghinia) one equation model (OEM). Their
study showed that the RAST OEM produced the most
reasonable results. In a recent work, Taghinia et al. [18]
simulated a simple shape of the human body applying
three LES SGS (sub-grid scale) and one DES models.
Furthermore, the effect of radiation from the occupant's
body was considered in some cases. Comparisons with the
experimental data proved that the ZEM and WALE
models provided an accurately prediction of velocity and
temperature profiles. Based on these previous studies, it is
clear that the use of an adequate turbulence model is
crucial for the study of aerodynamic characteristics inside
the building. Furthermore, the boundary conditions
variations have a significant impact on the numerical
simulation. In this respect, Mohammed [19] used the zero
equation model to study the effect of the inlet temperature
and the velocity on the indoor air quality and the thermal
comfort. He confirmed that a low inlet velocity can
provide a very good condition in the environment.
Martinho et al. [20] investigated the inlet boundary