Please cite this article in press as: Race, K., The use of pleasure in harm reduction: Perspectives from the History of Sexuality, International
Journal of Drug Policy (2007), doi:10.1016/j.drugpo.2007.08.008
ARTICLE IN PRESS
DRUPOL-715; No. of Pages 7
International Journal of Drug Policy xxx (2007) xxx–xxx
Review
The use of pleasure in harm reduction: Perspectives
from the History of Sexuality
Kane Race
*
Department of Gender and Cultural Studies, University of Sydney, NSW 2006, Australia
Received 23 April 2007; received in revised form 15 August 2007; accepted 17 August 2007
Abstract
The absence of pleasure in harm reduction discourse is more and more frequently noted, but few have considered what, exactly, more
attention to pleasure might do. What is the value of pleasure for harm reduction praxis? Central to such an inquiry is the question of how
pleasure is grasped, conceptually and methodologically. In this paper I use Foucault’s History of Sexuality to elaborate a perspective on the use
of pleasure within harm reduction. I argue that Foucault’s work suggests a distinction between therapeutic and social-pragmatic approaches to
pleasure, and that such a distinction is important for harm reduction – to the extent that it seeks to maintain a critical awareness of the relation
between stigma and care – in that the latter model raises the possibility of maintaining de-pathologizing modes of care. An appreciation of
pleasure in terms of its social pragmatics helps to recognize practices of safety, care and risk that might otherwise go unregistered in the
current punitive political environment. It provides a basis for conceiving practical measures that are in touch with given concerns and bodily
practices, and thus have more chance of being taken up. It also enables a more dynamic and responsive approach to the practice of bodies and
pleasures.
© 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Harm reduction theory; Pleasure; Ethics; Drugs; Self-care; Moralism
Introduction
In this article I use the History of Sexuality to discuss the
use of pleasure within harm reduction (Foucault, 1978, 1986,
1990). I have used this text to structure a graduate course on
harm reduction theory and practice, based at the National
Centre in HIV Social Research, called ‘Bodies, Habits and
Pleasures’. The course was designed to encourage students
to reflect critically on the social and political dynamics of
sex, drugs and public health; to develop skills in interdisci-
plinary practice; and to frame their projects within a broader
field of struggle and intervention. To this end, I combined
Foucault’s work with readings on sex and drugs from a range
of disciplines, including empirical social science.
The History of Sexuality provides an excellent basis for
framing social research and education in this field. Although
the text is dense, historical and philosophical – not the sort
*
Tel.: +612 9351 3662; fax: +612 9351 3556.
E-mail address: krace@usyd.edu.au.
of thing you are likely to hear much of in the mainstream
fields of public health, social policy and medicine – it pro-
vides one of the most trenchant and far-reaching analyses
of the involvement of the medical and human sciences in
the social maintenance of categories of deviance, normality
and abnormality. It gives us a way of thinking through the
regulative and coercive, as well as valuable and life-saving,
aspects of health and medicine. This is important in the con-
text of infectious diseases such as HIV and Hepatitis C, where
medicine provides important resources, but can also func-
tion as a source of oppression (Race, in press). Combined
with concepts from the second and third volumes, such as
the ‘use of pleasure’ and ‘care of the self’, the History of
Sexuality provides a basis for conceiving how subordinated
groups might make use of medicine in ways comparatively
less encumbered by the normalizing effects of psychological
and medical discourses. Enormously influential within HIV
activism around sexuality (Halperin, 1995), the utility of this
text for broader practices of harm reduction and drug pol-
icy is yet to be fully realized (Duff, 2004), and takes some
0955-3959/$ – see front matter © 2007 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.drugpo.2007.08.008