‘Dwelling’ with
ecotourism in the
Peruvian Amazon
Cultural relationships in local–global
spaces
Tazim Jamal and Amanda Stronza
Texas A&M University, USA
abstract This article argues for a perspective to ecotourism development that is not
determined solely by academics, capitalistic markets, conservationists or NGOs, but
also by locally defined and culturally embedded relations and meanings. We start with
a theoretical critique of ecotourism development and conservation at the intersection
of the macro-global and micro-local levels. Insights from the existential philosopher,
Martin Heidegger (1889–1976) help identify spaces and relationships in natural area
destinations that illustrate the paradox of ecological modernization. A longitudinal
case study of a community-based ecotourism initiative in the Peruvian Amazon is
used to illustrate our argument. Local residents work in partnership with a private tour
company to market and operate the lodge, but negotiations go beyond splitting profits
or commodifying resources. Members engage in and resist tourism-related changes in
multiple ways. Heidegger’s notions of dwelling and care (concern: Sorghe) introduces
a way of understanding such performative ecotourism spaces.
keywords care (concern: sorghe) dwelling; ecotourism development; Heidegger;
human–environmental relationships; Peruvian Amazon; social-cultural sustainability
Contesting the received view of ecotourism
This article builds on previous critique of the commodified frameworks and
development paradigms that currently guide ecotourism and sustainable tourism
(Wearing and Ponting, 2005). Sustainable tourism and ecotourism are both
rooted in notions of individual, societal and environmental well-being despite
their different origins. Sustainable tourism is related closely to the notion of
sustainable development as laid out by WCED (1987), where ‘balancing’
tourist studies
© 2009
sage publications
Los Angeles, London,
New Delhi, Singapore and
Washington DC
vol 8(3) 313-335
DOI: 10.1177/
1468797608100593
www.sagepublications.com
article
313
ts