Central
Annals of Orthopedics & Rheumatology
Cite this article: Tagoe CE (2013) Autoimmune Thyroiditis in Rheumatology Practice: Should we be Looking? Ann Orthop Rheumatol 1(1): 1003.
*Corresponding author
C le m e nt E. Ta g o e , Divisio n o f Rhe um a to lo g y, Alb e rt
Einste in C o lle g e o f Me d ic ine , Mo nte fio re Me d ic a l
C e nte r, 111 Ea st 210th Stre e t, Bro nx, USA 10467-
2490, Tel: 718-920-6661; Fax: 718-515-6103, Email:
c ta g o e @ a o l.c o m
Submitte d: 23 Oc to be r 2013
Accepted: 24 O c to b e r 2013
Publishe d: 25 O c to b e r 2013
Copyright
© 2013 Ta g o e
OPEN ACCESS
Editorial
Autoimmune Thyroiditis in
Rheumatology Practice: Should
we be Looking?
Clement E. Tagoe*
Department of Medicine, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, USA
Editorial
Chronic lymphocytic thyroiditis (CLT), a variant of
autoimmune thyroiditis (AIT) is the commonest autoimmune
disease with a prevalence of about 10% worldwide, rising to about
20% after age 50 years with a female to male preponderance of
about 9:1 [1,2]. Although it is generally asymptomatic, severe
disease can lead to failure of the thyroid gland and hypothyroidism
in about 20% of cases [2]. Less commonly known is the fact that
CLT and its goitrous form, Hashimoto thyroiditis, are associated
with a multitude of other clinical syndromes including nervous
system, psychological, dermatologic, metabolic, endocrine
and musculoskeletal conditions [3]. A variety of causative
mechanisms are probably involved including metabolic,
endocrine, autoimmune and perhaps inflammatory processes.
The association of CLT with other autoimmune conditions
including connective tissue diseases is also likely responsible for
the tremendous diversity of clinical presentations [4].
Despite the mounting evidence in the literature of
rheumatic diseases associated with CLT, the rheumatology
community remains largely unaware of the importance
of thyroid autoimmunity. The purely rheumatic disease
associations reported include chronic widespread pain
syndromes, fibromyalgia syndrome, osteoarthritis and erosive
osteoarthritis, inflammatory arthritis resembling rheumatoid
arthritis, calcium pyrophosphate dihydrate deposition disease
(CPPD), myositis, spinal degenerative disc disease, carpal tunnel
syndrome, Raynaud’s phenomenon, sicca symptoms, prolonged
morning stiffness, chronic fatigue syndrome, undifferentiated
connective tissue disease and several well-defined connective
tissue diseases [5]. The high prevalence of CLT and the high
proportion of CLT sufferers reported as having rheumatic
disease associations suggest that the numbers involved reach
epidemic proportions. However there are no well-designed
population-based studies examining the true prevalence of these
CLT-related clinical syndromes. Part of the problem is the very
fact of unusually high prevalence of thyroid autoimmunity. Thus
the “background” against which statistical significance must
be shown is extraordinarily high. Indeed because of that high
threshold only well-designed population-based data could yield
unequivocal results of disease causation. Coupled with that is the
fact that autoimmunity seldom occurs as an isolated phenomenon
making it difficult to separate the true causes of the rheumatic
associations. Current knowledge suggests that up to 50% of adult
CLT patients have another well-defined autoimmune process
[4]. Of course the spectrum of autoimmunity is so broad and
comprises several less clinically apparent conditions which can
go undiagnosed for prolonged periods, that the co-occurrence of
CLT with other autoimmune processes is probably higher still.
These less commonly diagnosed autoimmune processes include
autoimmune cytopenias, celiac disease, pernicious anemia,
myasthenia gravis and autoimmune neuropathies. Despite these
concerns regarding the difficulties with proving causation there
is growing and overwhelming evidence of the association of CLT
with several rheumatic phenomena.
Therefore the clinical relevance of finding CLT in patients
or their families is that it strengthens our suspicion for an
autoimmune etiology underlying their disease process. It also
provides an assessment of risk for several rheumatic conditions
associated with CLT including chronic widespread pain and
osteoarthritis. In some situations it probably provides the only
identifiable risk factor for that disease process as in the case
of osteoarthritis or chronic widespread pain in young patients
for whom no other reasonable explanations exist. Placing CLT
squarely within the pantheon of autoimmune diseases, which
preoccupy rheumatologists in particular and other healthcare
providers in general, would allow better definition of the
problems associated with it, a more scientific understanding
of the pathogenic mechanisms involved and more rational
therapies for patients with these conditions. It would also lay
the ground work for better classification of the associated
syndromes and encourage basic research into how thyroid
autoimmunity mediates the panoply of findings including
arthritis, chronic widespread pain and neuropathy. The high
accessibility of the thyroid gland relative to other organs should
facilitate any basic research efforts into its role in autoimmunity.
Several questions need to be addressed including whether
or not most of the conditions mentioned before are part of a
more generalized autoimmune process in CLT or are caused by
separate mechanisms of injury. We still do not know why the
thyroid gland is caught up in the autoimmunity associated with
rheumatoid arthritis or systemic lupus erythematosus in up to
25% of cases [4]. Most baffling is the fact that some patients