Issues in Reproductive and Genetic Engineering, Vol. 3, No. l, pp. 13-21, 1990 0958-6415/90 $3.00 + .00
Printed in the USA. Copyright © 1990 Pergamon Press plc
NEW REPRODUCTIVE TECHNOLOGIES IN INDIA:
A PRINT MEDIA ANALYSIS
LAKSHMI LINGAM
Women’s Studies Unit, Tata Institute of Social Sciences, Post
Box 8313, Deonar, Bombay, 400 088, India
Synopsis – Based on newspaper and magazine articles, the present paper explores the
status of the New Reproductive Technologies in India. The important aspect that is
observed is the remarkable difference in the coverage that is given to “test-tube babies”
versus sex-determination tests. While on the one hand the arrival of “test-tube babies”
receives a lot of fanfare and glorification in the media, on the other hand, due to the
widespread debate and campaigning against amniocentesis, the media coverage provides
divided opinions on sex-determination tests. To view these technologies as links in the
same chain, based on uniform ideologies, is crucial. This paper makes a contribution
towards this end.
Synopsis–
INTRODUCTION
Along with sustained protests against
unsafe oral contraceptives, the IUD
(Intra-Uterine Device), injectables, and
sex-determination tests, a new issue on
the agenda of the women’s movement in
India is to debate and take a stand on the
new reproductive technologies (NRTs)
and genetic engineering. Though
seemingly “new,” these technologies
have the same underlying ideology of
abusing, disrespecting, manipulating, and
exploiting women as “objects.” While the
former reproductive technologies were
anti-natal – primarily used as measures
of population control – the latter function
in a pro-natalist context where NRTs are
introduced as “therapeutic cure” for
infertile women. However, this
technology too is anti-woman for it is set
within the ideological structure of
“marriage,” “children within wedlock,”
“the supremacy of biological
motherhood,” and it reinforces fertility as
an important indicator of women’s status.
NKTs have great-er scope than indicated
13