Ethnic Disparities in Youth Access to Tobacco:
California Statewide Results, 1999-2003
Hope Landrine, PhD
Irma Corral, MS, MPH
Elizabeth A. Klonoff, PhD
Jennifer Jensen, MPH
Kennon Kashima, PhD
Norval Hickman, MS, MPH
Jonathan Martinez, MS
variables entailed in children’s desire to smoke (Pentz,
Bonnie, & Shopland, 1996; U.S. Department of Health
and Human Services [DHHS], 1994). Studies indicate
that supply (i.e., actual or perceived high access to
tobacco) may be as strong a predictor of youth smoking
as demand and may be the strongest predictor of initial
smoking among youths (e.g., DHHS, 1994; Klonoff &
Landrine, 2004; Landrine & Klonoff, 2003; Robinson,
Klesges, Zbikowski, & Glaser, 1997). For example, in a
study of more than 6,000 youths, Robinson et al. (1997)
found that perceived easy access to cigarettes was the
best predictor of youth experimentation with smoking
and indeed was a better predictor than well-known
demand variables such as peer and parental smoking.
Efforts to prevent youth smoking thereby focus on
reducing youth supply and/or demand, with data sug-
gesting that supply-side interventions may be more
cost-effective (e.g., Di Franza, 2005; DiFranza &
Dussault, 2005; DiFranza, Peck, Radecki, & Savageau,
2001; Forster et al., 1998). Moreover, each day, 3000-
4000 youths become regular smokers and hence
become the next generation of adult smokers (DHHS,
1994). Reducing youth access to tobacco is one strategy
that might prevent some percentage of current youth
and so of future adult smoking (Forster & Wolfson,
The authors examined the role of youth ethnicity in
youth access to tobacco with large, random samples of
stores and large samples of ethnically diverse youths
for the first time. From 1999 through 2003, White,
Black, Latino, and Asian youths made 3,361 cigarette
purchase attempts (approximately 700 per year)
statewide. Analyses revealed that Black youths had sig-
nificantly higher access than other youths and that
access rates for Black and Asian (but not Latino or
White) youths exceeded the Synar-mandated ≤ 20%.
Clerks who failed to demand youth proof of age identi-
fication (ID) sold 95% of the tobacco that youths
received and sold significantly more often to minorities
and to girls, whereas clerks who demanded youth ID
sold equally infrequently to all youths. These findings
highlight significant ethnic disparities in youth access
to tobacco and imply that those might be eliminated by
policies and interventions that increase clerk demands
for youth ID.
Keywords: youth access to tobacco; ethnic disparities;
smoking; primary prevention
S
moking among youths (12- to 17-year-olds) can be
understood as a function of supply and demand,
where supply refers to youth access to (ability to
acquire) cigarettes and demand refers to the psychosocial
Health Promotion Practice
Month XXXX Vol. XX, No. XX, xx-xx
DOI: 10.1177/1524839908317230
© 2008 Society for Public Health Education
Authors’ Note: This study was supported by funds provided by
National Cancer Institute Grants No. 1-U56-CA92079-01A1,
5F31-CA110213-01, and 5F31-CA103135-03; by Tobacco-Related
Disease Research Program Grant No. 9RT-0043 and 15 AT-1300;
and by California Department of Health Services Tobacco
Control Section Grants 94-20962 and 96-26617. Please address
correspondence to Hope Landrine, PhD, American Cancer Society,
250 Williams Street, Atlanta, GA 30303; phone: (404) 329-4425;
e-mail: Hope.Landrine@cancer.org.
1
Health Promot Pract OnlineFirst, published on May 14, 2008 as doi:10.1177/1524839908317230
Copyright 2008 by Society for Public Health Education.