ORIGINALARBEITEN/ORIGINALS
DOI 10.1007/s10010-017-0221-5
Forsch Ingenieurwes (2017) 81:207–213
Investigation on the flank surface durability of gears with increased
pressure angle
Christian Weber
1
· Thomas Tobie
1
· Karsten Stahl
1
Received: 10 April 2017
© Springer-Verlag GmbH Deutschland 2017
Abstract Within a funded research project (reference num-
ber 0325244C, BMWi – Federal Ministry for Economic Af-
fairs and Energy of Germany), the load-carrying capacity of
alternative involute gears was investigated. To find qualified
variations for use in gear drives, increased pressure angles
(αn > 20°) and/or asymmetric tooth shapes (αn < 20° and
αn > 20°) have been examined experimentally. Optimization
goals were the power to weight ratio of the transmission and
the power density in the drive train.
In this report gears with reference tooth shape (αn = 20°)
as well as gears with modified tooth shape (αn = 28°) are dis-
cussed with focus on the load carrying capacity of the tooth
flank with special regard to the damage mechanisms pitting,
micro-pitting and scuffing. The results of experimental and
test accompanying studies are shown. They allow a direct
comparison between standard and special gears as well as
a classification in context of the actual state of knowledge.
1 Introduction and objective
Mechanical engineering uses almost exclusively symmetric
involute gears with pressure angles αn 20° according to
the basic rack as specified in ISO 53 [7] in today’s power
transmitting gear drives. Besides the economic advantages
of the manufacturing process using straight-flank hobbing
tools the broad application of this toothing is due to its
uniform transmission of motion. This even applies to shaft
center distance deviations from the setpoint.
Christian Weber
c.weber@fzg.mw.tum.de
1
Gear Research Centre (FZG), Technical University of
Munich, Garching, Germany
For the design of symmetric involute toothings with
αn 20° comprehensive calculation tools and methods such
as ISO 6336 [6] are available. These calculation methods
are based on extensive theoretical and experimental stud-
ies on appropriate standard gears and are well-proven for
years. Nevertheless, these calculation methods do not claim
to universal validity. The calculation method according to
ISO 6336 [6] for example is limited to a pressure angle of
αn 25° according to the basic rack specified in ISO 53 [7].
However, for a reliable application of special involute
gears with an increased pressure angle in industrially run-
ning transmissions a comprehensive and confirmed iden-
tification and verification of the load-carrying capacities is
needed for such toothings. This also requires an experimen-
tal verification of existing tooth flank load-carrying capacity
calculation methods.
2 Investigated failure mechanisms
The herein described experimental investigations were car-
ried out in order to determine the flank load carrying ca-
pacity against the most common gear failures, i. e. pitting,
micro-pitting, and scuffing. For all tests regarding the listed
types of flank failures, selective tests have been performed.
The operating conditions were adjusted to cause the desired
type of flank failures, if necessary.
Furthermore, investigations concerning the tooth root
bending strength of gears with increased pressure angles
as well as of gears with asymmetric tooth shape were done
[14]. The aim of these investigations was amongst others
the validation of the advanced calculation method for tooth
root bending strength according to FZG/Fröh [13]. The re-
sults of these investigations are no object of this paper.
K