Met. Mater. Int., Vol. 19, No. 4 (2013), pp. 731~740
doi: 10.1007/s12540-013-4012-8
Imitating Seasonal Temperature Fluctuations for the H
2
S Corrosion of 304L
and 316L Austenitic Stainless Steels
A. Davoodi
1,
*
, M. Babaiee
2
, and M. Pakshir
3
1
Hakim Sabzevari University, Faculty of Engineering, Materials Science and Polymer
Engineering Department, Sabzevar, 391, Iran
2
Shiraz University, School of Engineering, Department of Materials Science and Engineering,
Shiraz, 713451154, Iran
3
Shiraz University, School of Engineering, Department of Materials Science and Engineering,
Shiraz, 713451154, Iran
(received date: 6 January 2012 / accepted date: 3 September 2012)
Temperature fluctuations are inevitable in sour oil and gas production. In this study, the H2S corrosion of
304L and 316L alloys was investigated at pH 3 and temperatures of 20-60
°
C using DC and AC electro-
chemical techniques. Two-fold increases in the corrosion rates of both alloys were reported with increases
in temperature to 60
°
C. In the 304L alloy, the surface layer was observed to be 3% rougher and 34%
thicker than that of the 316L alloy. The two alloys exhibited different corrosion behaviors in the tempera-
ture ranges of 20-40
°
C and 40-60
°
C. Although the 316L alloy revealed a greater corrosion resistance at
the free potential condition, the passivation on the 304L alloy was significantly greater than that of the
316L alloy at 40
°
C and 15 ppm H2S. The FeS2 and combined FeS2-MoS2 compounds contributed to the
surface layer constituents in the 304L and 316L alloys, respectively. The increase in temperature kinetically
provided more favorable conditions for FeS2 than MoS2 formation, i.e. it had a relatively constructive
effect on the 304L alloy passivation.
Key words: alloys, corrosion, electrochemistry, microstructure, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), X-ray diffraction
1. INTRODUCTION
Stainless steel grades 304L and 316L are commonly used
construction materials for piping, stationary, and rotary equip-
ment that come in contact with corrosive environments during
the production of hydrocarbon fluids [1,2]. Their corrosion
resistance is attributed to the passive film formation on the
alloy surface and the difference observed in the corrosion
behavior of the 304L and 316L alloys has been associated
with the additional molybdenum alloying element in the 316L
alloy. It has been demonstrated that molybdenum partici-
pates in the surface reactions and enhances the protective-
ness of the surface layer [3].
Nevertheless, the presence of hydrogen sulfide, carbon
dioxide, dissolved salt, and water in the produced hydrocar-
bon fluids deteriorates the alloy passivity [4-6].The presence
of the abovementioned contaminations becomes even more
frequent as the exploitation of deep reservoirs increases and
unconventional resources are increasingly used [2,7]. Despite
several attempts to remove these contaminations [2,8-11],
their presence is inevitable due to practical process restriction.
Among these impurities, the presence of hydrogen sulfide
in produced oil and gas results in operational, environmental,
and treatment problems. The procedure of selecting either
the 304L or 316L alloy as the paramount alloy, from both an
economical and performance viewpoint, is affected by the
simultaneous influence of two kinetics parameters: the H
2
S
concentration and temperature [12]. High temperature H
2
S
corrosion on stainless steel has been reported recently and it
was stated that the high concentration of sulfur in the sulfu-
rated compounds favors the formation of extremely aggres-
sive acids, such as H
2
SO
4
, which contribute to an accelerated
and intense corrosion process of the stainless steel [13].
Three natural processes are proposed in order to explain
the H
2
S accumulations in the reservoirs: bacterial sulfate
reduction (BSR), thermal cracking or thermal decomposition
of sulfides (TDS), and thermochemical sulfate reduction (TSR)
[7,14-17]. In addition, secondary H
2
S could also be induced
during the steam injection recovery process of heavy oil and
gas [7]. In the southern Persian Gulf, the proposed TSR is a
significant mechanism for obtaining high H
2
S content, whereas
the other processes, such as BSR and organic sulfur origi-
nated from the TDS of kerogen and/or oil, are also possible
*Corresponding author: adavoodi@kth.se
©KIM and Springer, Published 10 July 2013