e173 The Tragic Tale of a Father and Son: an Unusual Patricide
The Tragic Tale of a Father and Son: an Unusual Patricide
G. Divella
1
, I. Grattagliano
3
, M. C. Romanelli
2
, J.B. Duval
4
, R. Catanesi
3
1
Section of Legal Medicine, Department of Public Health and Pediatric, University of Turin;
2
Section of Legal Medicine, Interdisci-
plinary Department of Medicine, University of Bari;
3
Section of Criminology and Forensic Psychyatric, Interdisciplinary Department
of Medicine, University of Bari, Italy;
4
Indiana, US
Case report
Clin Ter 2017; 168 (3):e173-177. doi: 10.7417/T.2017.2000
Correspondence: Ignazio Grattagliano, Section of Criminology and Forensic Psychyatric, Interdisciplinary Department of Medicine, University
of Bari, Italy. Bari, Italy. Tel: +39 080 5478364; Fax: +39- 080 5478248. E-mail: ignazio.grattagliano@uniba.it
Copyright © Società Editrice Universo (SEU)
ISSN 1972-6007
Introduction
Parricide (1-2),is the killing of one’s own biological or
adoptive parent. Parricide is subdivided into patricide (the
killing of one’s father), matricide (the killing of one’s mo-
ther), and “double parricide” (the killing of both parents).
Statistically, parricide is the rarest of all categories of vo-
luntary manslaughter. In Europe and North America, it is
estimated that parricide accounts for 2-4% of all homicides
there, with patricides outnumbering matricides. In Europe
parricides are more numerous in Eastern Europe, Russia first
of all ( 3-4). In Italy, parricide accounts for less than 3% of
all homicides, with matricides outnumbering patricides. The
40.1% of the cases concerns the North, 28.4% took place
in the South, the16.1% in the central belt of Italy, 15.4%
in the islands (5). This kind of homicide most often occurs
in homes where the aggressor and victim cohabitate, and
happens most frequently after an altercation, (6). Parricide
is often perpetrated in a violent and bloody manner, at
times comparable to that of overkilling, and often with the
use of a common household object found inside the home,
(7), Patricide is mostly carried out by males (8), and there
Abstract
Parricide is a category of homicide in which the victims are
the parents, and the killers, their children. The authors report a case
of a 45-year-old man who killed his 73-year-old widowed father in
an extremely violent manner: he struck the father in the head with a
wooden wash board, stabbed him with a pair of scissors and several
times with a screwdriver. Afterwards, he kicked the victim in the face
and jumped up and down on his body, thereby crushing the father’s
chest with his weight. The case reported here may be classified as an
“unusual patricide” when one considers the age of the aggressor, the
diagnosis of psychiatric disorders, that the victim was the father, and
that the murder was committed in an extremely violent manner. Clin
Ter 2017; 168(3):e173-177. doi: 10.7417/CT.2017.2000
Key words: patricide, violence, forensic pathology, overkilling,
forensic psychiatry
are a variety of motives that induce adolescents or adults to
commit it (9). When adolescents commit parricide, it is often
a violent reaction to physical and sexual abuse perpetrated
by the father on his children, or on their mother, over a
protracted period of time ( 10-11). However, when parricide
is carried out by adults between 30 and 40 years of age, it
most often involves serious psychiatric pathologies - mostly
psychotic. When the murder is the result of dysfunctional
family relationships(12-13), it is most often the mother who
is the victim.
In the various cases examined, the perpetrators of these
crimes are typically unmarried, unemployed, or work part-
time, and they usually live with the victim. In one study
carried out on a sample of 12 men with an average age of
31 years old, six subjects had tried to kill both parents, and
the other six had killed one parent.
In this case record, drug and alcohol abuse, which are
considered to be precipitating factors, was present in 41.7%
of cases. In addition, serious recurring problems concerning
mental health issues and the inability to live autonomou-
sly were also reported. All of these factors compelled the
subjects to live with their families (14).
Other authors have also (15), revealed a predominance
of males, combined with other factors such as living with
the parents, financial dependence on the family, and limited
relationships or other activities that take place outside of
the home. The subjects experience this as a sense of being
“trapped”, which contributes to strife in the parent/child
relationship. Globally, the predominance of males in the
commission parricide is correlated to their propensity for
committing violent acts, and is not influenced by the ethnic
group to which they belong.
Case report
The perpetrator of this homicide is a 45-year-old man
with a low level of education (elementary school) who
had worked in the construction industry, but who had been
unemployed for an extended period of time. He was the only
male of six children. This man, reserved and introverted by