International Journal of Mechanical & Mechatronics Engineering IJMME-IJENS Vol:19 No:04 18
191204-5858-IJMME-IJENS © August 2019 IJENS
I J E N S
Multi-Objective Control of Utility-scale
Variable-Speed Wind Turbines for Drive-train Load
Reduction in Low Wind Speed Regime
Edwin Kipchirchir
1*
, Jackson G. Njiri
2
and Stanley I. Kamau
3
1
Edwin Kipchirchir, Department Mechatronic Engineering, PAUSTI.
2
Jackson G. Njiri, Department of Mechatronic Engineering, JKUAT.
3
Stanley I. Kamau, Department of Electrical Engineering, JKUAT.
*
Edwin Kipchirchir - Email: edwin.kipchirchir@jkuat.ac.ke.
Abstract-- Wind turbines are important in capturing power
from varying wind speed. For maximum energy capture in low
wind speed regime, a standard generator torque controller is
normally used to track the incoming wind speed in order to
maximize power production. In low wind speed regime, the rotor
blade pitch angles are held constant at an optimum value that
ensures maximum lift. This control strategy has some limitations,
especially in large wind turbines due to induced structural loads.
Though aerodynamic loads are not high in the low wind speed
regime, maximum power point tracking can cause high torque
variations in the drive-train which can lead to early fatigue
failure of the wind turbine. Most studies done in this regime
focuses on maximum energy capture, without considering
structural loads, which are critical in large wind turbines that
have large inertial loads. In this paper, a multi-objective control
strategy that ensures utility scale wind turbines capture
maximum power in low wind speed regime, while minimizing
drive-train vibrations is proposed. An optimal generator torque
controller is designed to achieve maximum energy capture, while
an independent blade pitch controller is designed to reduce drive-
train vibrational loads in the wind turbine. The two controllers
are designed in MATLAB and simulated in Fatigue,
Aerodynamics, Structural and Turbulence (FAST) software.
TurbSim full-field turbulent wind simulator is used to generate
varying wind profiles for simulation purposes. A fictitious 1.5
MW WindPACT wind turbine model is used to evaluate the
proposed control strategy. When evaluated against a baseline
controller for the low wind speed regime under stochastic wind
excitation, the multi-objective control strategy improves drive-
train torsional damping by 2.69%, with standard deviation
decreasing by 3.28%, without compromising on power capture.
Index Term-- Horizontal axis wind turbine (HAWT), linear
quadratic gaussian (LQG), maximum power point tracking
(MPPT), variable-speed wind turbine (VSWT), independent
pitch control (IPC), optimal tracking rotor (OTR).
INTRODUCTION
WIND turbines are used to capture power from varying wind
speed. Being a renewable source of energy, it reduces reliance
on fossil fuel-based energy sources that are harmful to the
environment. With time, as the world population grows and
economies expand, there is increasingly high demand for
energy from renewable sources. Wind is most competitive and
preferred renewable energy source due to its minimal negative
impact on the environment [1]. This has led to rapid growth in
demand for wind energy generation, necessitating wind
turbine manufacturers to produce larger wind turbines. There
are increased structural loads with increase in wind turbine
size, which is attributed to gravitational loads, inertial,
centrifugal, and gyroscopic loads which occur during
operation. These structural loads can drastically reduce the
lifetime of a wind turbine. Therefore, there is need to design
control strategies to reduce structural loads in wind turbines.
In a variable speed wind turbine, power production occurs in
the low wind speed regime (below the rated wind speed
region), and the high wind speed regime (above the rated wind
speed region). Most wind turbines operate in the low wind
speed regime, whose main objective is to maximize the
amount of power extracted by the wind turbine. Therefore, the
rotational speed of the generator should be adjusted in real
time in relation to the incoming wind speed [2]. The main
objective in the high wind speed regime is to regulate the rotor
speed and power so as to avoid exceeding mechanical and
electrical limits of the wind turbine. To lower the cost of
energy production, there is a growing need for energy
efficiency for wind turbines operating in the low wind speed
regime. This is attained by operating the wind turbine at
optimum power efficiency as much as possible. Proper design
of controllers for Wind Energy
Conversion Systems (WECS), ensures efficient energy
generation, good power quality, and reduced mechanical
and aerodynamic loads resulting in increased turbine life [3].
Utility-scale wind turbines normally have Horizontal Axis
Wind Turbine (HAWT) configuration due to its advantages
over Vertical Axis Wind Turbine (VAWT) configuration. One
advantage is being able to mount the entire rotor on top of a
tall tower in order to take advantage of higher wind speeds.
Variable pitch and speed operation, improved structural
performance, and elimination of guy wires used to add
structural stability are the other advantages of HAWTs [4].
Wind turbines rotor blades can be fixed pitch or pitch-able.
Though fixed pitch blades are cheap to manufacture, variable-
pitch blades are preferred for large wind turbines since it
reduces induction of structural loads during operation. Most
modern utility scale wind turbines are designed to have
variable pitch and speed in order to capture as much energy as
possible by the rotor speed tracking the incoming wind speed
[5]. In contrast to constant speed wind turbines, Variable