Journal of Scientific Research and Development 3 (4): 133-137, 2016
Available online at www.jsrad.org
ISSN 1115-7569
© 2016 JSRAD
133
Application of ecological attributes in the contemporary landscape assessment
research
Jamilah Othman
*
, Muhammad Faris Abdullah, Azila Ahmad Sarkawi, Fadzidah Abdullah, NurEmira Ahmad
Kamaruddin
Kulliyyah of Architecture and Environmental Design, International Islamic University Malaysia
Abstract: Ecological attributes are most commonly associated to nature-based landscape assessment. But their
applications are less discussed in the non-nature based landscape assessment. This paper reviews a collection of 31
journal articles, which were published between 1974 and 2015. The results show that ecological attributes such as
water, vegetation and landform, have increasingly featured in various studies on non-nature based landscape
assessment studies. This suggests that ecological attributes can support and enhance the assessment of both nature-
and non-nature-based landscapes significantly. To this end, this paper also proposes a preliminary ecological model
for landscape assessment research.
Key words: Ecological attributes; Scenic beauty; Landscape assessment
1. Introduction
*
Ecological attributes are more commonly applied
to nature-based landscape assessment but less on
non-nature-based landscape assessment. Previous
work by scholars such as Daniel (2001); Palmer
(2008); Jamilah, (2011) and etc., which have focused
heavily on the application of ecological attributes in
the nature-based landscape may have, in part, give
credence to this prevalent misconception. Ecology is
always closely linked to landscape quality and
landscape assessment. High concern and interest in
scenic landscapes with ecological issues can be
found in the studies of Jogensen (2011); Kovacs,
LeRoy, Fischer, Lubarsky and Burke (2006); Parsons
and Daniel (2002) and Daniel (2001). This suggests
that application of ecological attributes in landscape
assessment should be more widespread and, should
not limited to nature-based landscape assessment
only. This paper reviews a collection of journal
articles to identify the common ecological attributes
that have been used in both nature- and non-nature-
based landscape assessment studies.
The aim is to show that ecological attributes are
importantly relevant in both types of landscape
assessment. It is hoped that the findings from this
study would provide the impetus for further
researches and developments on landscape
assessment methods, especially where ecological
attributes play a greater role in the non-nature-
based landscape assessment.
2. Landscape assessment
*
Corresponding Author.
Scenic beauty is among the landscape values,
which is assessed using expert, public experiential,
cognitive and psychophysical methods (Zube et al.,
1982). Sometimes researcher uses Scenic Beauty
Assessment (SBA) to determine healthy
environment that would be the basis to landscape
integrity, which involves visual interpretation of the
landscapes perceived. This involves scenic
preferences for different types of landscape (Unwin,
1975). The method describes the manner, where
peoples of various backgrounds interpret and judge
a landscape. The results of the assessment should be
easily understood and applied for better landscape
management practices, landscape design and
planning decisions. The method was clearly stated in
the work of Zube et al. (1982).
In the design-based research, quantifying scenic
quality should be the consequence of a management
action (Buhyoff et al., 1994). Importantly, many
ecological attributes of a landscape are important
indicators of the health of an environment. Scenic
value might be the primary indicator to an intrinsic
landscape, since it triggers positive responses in
people (Anderson and Schroeder, 1983). The value
would also be the indicator to guide and plan for
better management of public landscapes with
ecological value (Jamilah et al., 2011).
3. Ecological attributes
Some ecological values should be restored or
screened as early as the planning stage for balance
ecosystems and sustainable environment (Beer and
Higgins, 1990). Scenic landscapes can be associated
with valuable ecology and healthy environment.
There are some ecological attributes that have
strongly influenced the scenic beauty of a natural