International Journal of Hospitality Management 102 (2022) 103149
Available online 10 January 2022
0278-4319/© 2022 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Occupational stigma and career commitment: Testing mediation and
moderation effects of occupational self-esteem
☆
Hediye Kusluvan
a, 1
, Orhan Akova
b, 2
, Salih Kusluvan
c, *, 3
a
Hediye Kusluvan is a freelance lecturer and researcher in Istanbul, Turkey
b
Orhan Akova is a professor of tourism management at the Department of Tourism Management, Faculty of Economics, Istanbul University, Istanbul, Turkey
c
Salih Kusluvan is a professor of tourism management at the Faculty of Tourism, Istanbul Medeniyet University, Istanbul, Turkey
A R T I C L E INFO
Keywords:
Occupational stigma
Occupational self-esteem
Career commitment
Tourism and hospitality industries
Mediation and moderation
ABSTRACT
This study analyses the neglected role of occupational self-esteem as an intervening mediator and moderator
variable between perceived occupational stigma and career commitment. The study develops two conceptual
models and several hypotheses regarding the roles of occupational stigma and occupational self-esteem on career
commitment. To test the hypothesis and models, a total of 1000 responses from undergraduate tourism and
hospitality management students were collected using self-report scales. The fndings suggest that occupational
stigma has a total negative effect, as well as direct and indirect negative effects through occupational self-esteem,
on career commitment. Occupational self-esteem has a positive effect on career commitment and plays a partial
mediator role between occupational stigma and career commitment. The effect of occupational stigma on career
commitment is not dependent on the level of occupational self-esteem. The research has important conceptual
and practical implications for increasing prospective employees’ career commitment.
1. Introduction
A large proportion of tourism and hospitality management un-
dergraduates worldwide do not intend to take up employment in
tourism and hospitality industries (THIs) and many leave their jobs and
the industry shortly after a period of work following graduation (Cheng
and Tung, 2019; O’Leary and Deegan, 2005). One of the reasons that
account for low school to work/industry transfer and short careers in the
THIs include ‘stigma consciousness’ or occupational stigma (Shigihara,
2018; Wildes, 2005) and poor/low social image/status of some of
tourism and hospitality jobs (THJs) (Brien, 2004; Jiang and Tribe,
2009). Although the effect of stigma consciousness and low social status
regarding some of THJs is acknowledged and studied as a cause of
tourism and hospitality students’ and employee’s avoidance of line-level
tourism and hospitality occupations (THOs), the knowledge about the
effects of occupational stigma, stigma consciousness or low status of jobs
on employee turnover or commitment relies on bivariate relationships
and fndings. Little is known about the process by which perception of
stigma regarding THOs unfolds into employee withdrawal or why and
how occupational stigma reduces prospective or actual employee’s
career commitment (Shigihara, 2018). Similarly, limited research has
explored the intervening factors that may buffer the negative effect of
stigma consciousness on prospective or actual employees’ work and
career outcomes (Wildes, 2007). To obtain a better understanding of the
effects of occupational stigma on career commitment, the contingencies
of this relationship, including an emphasis on its mediators and mod-
erators, need to be examined. This paper argues that occupational
self-esteem has the potential to be the critical intervening variable that
explains the process or mechanism by which occupational stigma
damages prospective or actual employees’ commitment to occupations
in the THIs. It also suggests that depending on its level, occupational
self-esteem may be the critical factor to resist the negative effect of
☆
This study is based on PhD thesis of Dr Hediye Kusluvan titled ‘The impact of occupational stigma consciousness of undergraduate tourism management students
on occupational commitment: Mediating and moderating role of occupational self-esteem’. Social Science Institute of Istanbul University. Istanbul. Prof. Dr Orhan
Akova is the supervisor of the thesis. Prof. Dr Salih Kusluvan has contributed to the statistical analysis and writing of the article in English.
* Correspondence to: Acıbadem Mah. Cakmak Sitesi Sok., Cakmak Sitesi G Blok Daire:18, Kadıkoy, 34718 Istanbul, Turkey.
E-mail addresses: skusluvan@gmail.com, salih.kusluvan@medeniyet.edu.tr (S. Kusluvan).
1
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1874-3174.
2
https://orcid.org/0000-0001-7740-2938.
3
https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8746-6839.
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
International Journal of Hospitality Management
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/ijhm
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhm.2022.103149
Received 28 March 2021; Received in revised form 30 December 2021; Accepted 4 January 2022