A
Artisanal Knowledge and
Craftsmanship
Bert De Munck
Centre for Urban History/Urban Studies Institute,
University of Antwerp, Antwerp, Belgium
Keywords
Apprenticeship · Artisanal epistemology ·
Arts · Citizenship · Creativity · Episteme ·
Guilds · Ingenuity · Innovation · Invention ·
Labor · Liberal arts · Mechanical arts · Political
subjectivity · Rhetoric · Science · Senses ·
Skills · Techne · Technology
Introduction: The Politics of Artisanal
Knowledge
A clear definition of artisanal knowledge is diffi-
cult to present, as it is a contested field during the
early modern period. Today artisanal knowledge
is often referred to with the term “craft,” but as
Glenn Adamson (2013) has rightfully argued, this
originates in the late eighteenth and nineteenth
century, when craftsmanship was considered the
“other” of “modernity,” Following Adamson
(2013: xiii), craft emerged as “a coherent idea”
and as a “defined terrain” only in opposition to
industrialization: “Craft was not a static backdrop
against which industry emerged (...), the two
were created alongside one another, each defined
against the other through constant juxtaposition.”
Consequently, the concept of craft and craftsman-
ship cannot be used as an analytic lens to look at
the preindustrial period unproblematically. The
challenge is rather to understand the conceptuali-
zation of craftsmanship, or artisanal knowledge,
prior to the mid-eighteenth century.
Although the enduring importance of hands-on
skills has been pointed at for the nineteenth cen-
tury as well, artisans faced increasing mechaniza-
tion and technological innovation, resulting in
division of labor and deskilling for a least part of
the labor force (Samuel 1977, 1992; Berg 1980;
Sabel and Zeitlin 1985). In contrast to this, we
might be tempted to see late medieval and early
modern artisanal knowledge as something akin to
art, stressing the lack of alienation and division of
labor, the sophistication of the skills involved, and
the autonomy of the artist. This would still be
reductive however. Among nineteenth-century
conservative intellectuals, artisanal knowledge
was surrounded by nostalgia for the late medieval
period because the labor of artisans would have
been embedded in a deeply religious and ordered
society in which artisanal skills and knowledge
were not disconnected from the artisans’ piety and
virtue. While such nostalgic views culminated in
the famous Arts and Crafts movement in the late
nineteenth and early nineteenth century, they cast
their shadow into the late twentieth and early
twenty-first century, where they, for instance, tran-
spire in the work of Richard Sennett (2008), who
not only refers to craft knowledge as “an
© Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2020
D. Jalobeanu, C. T. Wolfe (eds.), Encyclopedia of Early Modern Philosophy and the Sciences,
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-20791-9_237-1