NONINVASIVE TWO-DIMENSIONAL TEMPERATURE IMAGING FOR GUIDANCE OF
THERMAL THERAPY
Emad S. Ebbini
University of Minnesota Twin Cities
Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering
ABSTRACT
Two-dimensional temperature estimation using pulse-echo di-
agnostic ultrasound has been previously described [5, 6, 8].
Measurement models in both time and frequency domains
have been proposed. In [5], spectral shifts in the echo data
have been shown to be proportional to changes in the local
tissue temperature. In [7, 8], echo shifts were shown to be
proportional to local change in tissue temperature. For both
the spectral and echo shift methods, the proportionality was
shown to be proportional to the local changes in the speed
of sound and local tissue expansion. However, temperature
images suffer from some artifacts due to the distortion of the
imaging beam as it traverses the heated region. In particu-
lar, temperature imaging artifacts due to the thermoacoustic
lens effects have been reported [7, 10]. In addition, tissue
inhomogeneity leads to nonuniform speckle patterns which
also lead to errors in the estimated temperature profiles. A re-
constructive imaging method employing a physics-based 2D
filter and a projection method is presented. The method of
projection onto convex sets (POCS) is used. Experimental
data was obtained during controlled temperature heating of in
vitro bovine muscle using a helical RF ablation probe. Re-
constructions using the POCS-based iterative algorithm are
shown to produce artifact-free temperature fields. Both spa-
tial and temporal characteristics of the reconstructed temper-
ature conform well with the extent of the heating source and
the temporal dynamics of the controlled temperature. These
results demonstrate that noninvasive temperature imaging of
a relatively large heating region (nearly 3 cm in diameter) can
be reliably monitored using pulse-echo ultrasound with ap-
propriate signal and image processing.
1. INTRODUCTION
Noninvasive temperature estimation continues to attract atten-
tion as a means of monitoring and guidance for minimally-
invasive thermotherapy. Currently, minimally-invasiveRF ab-
lation is the most commonly used form of thermal therapy, but
Funded in Part by Army Grant DAMD 17-01-1330. Parts of this work
were funded under Grant CA 66602 from the National Institutes of Health.
other techniques are being used or investigated. For exam-
ple, high-intensity focused ultrasound (HIFU) is being evalu-
ated clinically as a form of noninvasive thermal therapy. Suc-
cessful implementation of noninvasive temperature estima-
tion will be a boon for thermal therapy as it becomes less in-
vasive and as the heating sources become more sophisticated.
Currently, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and ultra-
sound have both been proven to have the temperature sen-
sitivity and spatial resolution necessary to provide noninva-
sive temperature feedback. The main limitation for MRI is
the cost and the potential complication of the heating proto-
col as the heating equipment must be MR compatible. Ultra-
sound is relatively less expensive, portable, and can be used in
conjunction with almost any heating protocol without adding
any significant constraints. Therefore, noninvasive tempera-
ture estimation based on ultrasound echo data continues to be
an important problem in the area of image-guided minimally-
invasive thermal therapy.
2. TEMPERATURE ESTIMATION
The temperature change estimation method in this paper is
based on the thermal dependence of the ultrasound echo that
accounts for two different physical phenomena: local change
in speed of sound and thermal expansion of the propagat-
ing medium due to changes in temperature. The speed of
sound c is a function of temperature. In most tissue media
around body temperature, c increases with temperature in the
range (see [2]). In fatty tissues, c decreases with increasing
temperature[4].
In [5], we have described a temperature measurement equa-
tion of the form:
Δf
k
(T ) ≈
k
2
∂c(T )
∂T
1
d(T )
|T=T
0
−
∂d(T )
∂T
|T =T
0
c(T )
d
2
(T )
ΔT, (1)
which relates the change in tissue temperature to changes in
harmonic frequencies related to the mean scanner spacing [6].
Strictly speaking, T
0
is function of space and time. However,
in practice, the proportionality constant in Equation 1 is con-
stant for a range of ΔT up to 15
◦
C from normal body tem-
perature. Therefore, it is reasonable to assume T
0
constant
throughout the temperature range of interest. Note that for
884 0-7803-9577-8/06/$20.00 ©2006 IEEE ISBI 2006