International Journal of Recent Technology and Engineering (IJRTE)
ISSN: 2277-3878, Volume-8 Issue-6, March 2020
2531
Retrieval Number: F8511038620/2020©BEIESP
DOI:10.35940/ijrte.F8511.038620
Published By:
Blue Eyes Intelligence Engineering
& Sciences Publication
Abstract: Currently there has been a research gap in providing
sufficient and reliable data for the estimation of surface runoff
from ungauged catchment in Batang Kuranji watershed, City of
Padang, West Sumatera, Indonesia. The need for such data arose
from the fact that land cover changes occur rapidly in the past 20
years, and flash flood and river degradation have been
experienced at an alarming scale. However, due to lack of
discharge data from upstream catchment, modelling catchment
response to the effect of land use changes is hampered. Field
measurement is difficult due to accessibility to river tributaries in
the upstream catchment. Therefore, the use of digital satellite
images and digital elevation model is studied with various DEM
(Digital Elevation Model) resolutions for the first time in this
catchment. This catchment is situated from 95 to 1858 m above sea
level with an annual rainfall of 3440 mm. This watershed is
classified as steep with a watershed that has a slope of more than
40% reaching 37.01% of the entire Kuranji watershed area. This
study used 30 m and 8 m DEM. Secondary data were gathered
from satellite images such as MODIS (MODerate resolution
Imaging Spectroradiometer) Land Use. Precipitation data were
gathered from three rain gauging stations in or nearby the
catchment. Stream geometry data were obtained from the
Provincial Office for River Management. Annual discharge and
100-year discharge are calculated using rainfall data for the past
20 years. Runoff discharge was calculated using rational method
and SCS (Soil Conservation Services) method. Overall, computed
discharge decreases as DEM resolution decreases with percentage
varies between 0.98% to 1.76%. The biggest difference between
DEM of 30 m and 8 m was shown by the Rational method.
However, the difference between years is inconsistent with
methods used with no significant pattern. Using the rational
method, the biggest difference was by 18.73 m3/s, making up
1.76%. With SCS-CN, however, the biggest difference was 14 m3/s
or 1.32% and the smallest was 0.98%. Validation with field
measurement suggests that the 8-m DEM varies only 0.16% with
actual discharge. Therefore, in the Kuranji catchment, the SCS
method coupled with 8-m DEM was found to be accurate for the
estimation of surface runoff.
Keywords: DEM, Land use, Runoff discharge.
I. INTRODUCTION
Padang City in West Sumatra, Indonesia has experienced a
shift in urban development and rapid population growth over
in last decade. The population of Padang City was 1.6 million
in 2010. Population growth for 5 years increased by 8% to 1.8
million (www.padangkota.bps.go.id) in 2015. This has led to
population growth and hence growing demands for public
Revised Manuscript Received on March 10, 2020.
* Correspondence Author
Elvi Roza Syofyan*, Civil Engineering Department, Politeknik Negeri
Padang, Padang, Indonesia. Email: syofyan_er@yahoo.co.id
Bambang Istijono, Civil Engineering Department, Faculty of
Engineering, University of Andalas, Padang, Indonesia.
Amrizal Saidi, Soil Department, Faculty of Agriculture, University of
Andalas, Padang, Indonesia.
Revalin Herdianto, Civil Engineering Department, Politeknik Negeri
Padang, Padang, Indonesia.
transportation facilities, residential areas and other
supporting facilities. In current global issues in climate
change, Padang is facing serious problems in
hydro-climatologic related disasters.
In the past 20 years, Batang Kuranji watershed has
experienced numerous problems related to hydrology. A
massive flash flood in the Year 2012 and continuous river
bed degradation has taken serious concerns on the health of
the watershed. Yet, there has been a research gap in providing
sufficient and reliable data for the estimation of surface
runoff from ungauged catchment in Batang Kuranji
watershed, City of Padang, West Sumatera, Indonesia. Due to
lack of discharge data from upstream catchment, modelling
catchment response to the effect of land use changes is
hampered
Numerical models can be used to predict runoff as an
insight to catchment response to various environmental
changes. HEC-HMS is one of the hydrological models in
the past that has been able to estimate runoff with various
accuracy between regions [1], [2], [3], [4]. Inputs required
are Digital Elevation Model (DEM), precipitation, stream
networks, land use, and other catchment conditions. DEM
may be obtained in various resolutions. With adequate sub
catchment arrangements, the results may give both
quantitative and qualitative information on hydrologic
response of catchments.
Climate change in recent years has been intensively studied as
a major cause of flood frequency [5], [6], [7]. Understanding
global and regional climate conditions over a longer period
is more important than local or catchment scale.
Furthermore, [5], [6], [7] recommended that characteristics
of flood must be understood by its causal mechanisms and
dominant processes over statistical approaches alone [5].
Climate change would change flood peak discharges.
Specifically, an increase in convective precipitation at a small
catchment may growth maximum flood discharge [6].
Similarly, atmospheric conditions particularly rainfall will
change magnitude of floods. Moreover, they highlighted that
apart from the atmosphere, river systems and catchment land
use changes are also attributed with the magnitude of
flooding [7].
In line with the aforementioned studies, land use changes
has an important roles because of its wide interactions with
many hydrologic parameters. Land use alteration and
management has been known to influence catchment
hydrology due to changes in evapotranspiration, infiltration,
antecedent soil moisture, and surface and subsurface storage
that eventually change surface runoff and stream flow [8].
Nevertheless, the direct connection is difficult to disentangle
because the processes are very complex on a long time scale.
Interception and infiltration of rainfall which ultimately
The Changes of Runoff with DEM Resolution
Variations
Elvi Roza Syofyan, Bambang Istijono, Amrizal Saidi, Revalin Herdianto