© 2016 Agung Sugiri and Imam Buchori. This open access article is distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution
(CC-BY) 3.0 license.
American Journal of Environmental Sciences
Original Research Paper
Towards Low Emission Development: Prospects of Applying
MBIs in the Industrial Sector of Central Java, Indonesia
Agung Sugiri and Imam Buchori
Department of Urban and Regional Planning, Diponegoro University, Semarang, Indonesia
Article history
Received: 10-02-2016
Revised: 27-05-2016
Accepted: 04-06-2016
Corresponding Author:
Agung Sugiri
Department of Urban and
Regional Planning, Diponegoro
University, Semarang,
Indonesia
Email: agung.sugiri@uqconnect.edu.au
Abstract: In dealing with pollution or emission, including in encouraging
Low Emission Development (LED) as an acceptable strategy for climate
change mitigation, Indonesia applies Command and Control (CAC)
approach through regulations on environmental and pollution standards.
However, the enforcement is characterized by weak monitoring and
controlling due to aspects like non-compliant industries and lack of
personnel and equipment of the corresponding agencies. Introducing
Market Based Instruments (MBIs) can help better achievement in LED as
evidenced in the USA, Australia, Taiwan, South Korea and Thailand. This
study aims to answer the question "how can the Central Java Provincial
Government (CJPG) facilitate better LED through the application of MBIs
in the industrial sector?" The approach is qualitative through in-depth
interviews with key persons from the CJPG and manufacturing industries
with high rate of greenhouse gas emissions in Semarang and Surakarta
metropolitans as the two largest industrial centers in Central Java. The
results show that the CJPG cannot apply MBI approach in its purely
theoretically forms. Instead, it is the principle, which is in accordance with
the Equity-Based Development model that should be integrated into the
CAC application, i.e., the polluters pay principle. The existing programs,
like PROPER, should be refined conceptually and enforced more widely to
accommodate ‘internalizing the externality’ principle better. More
industries should be encouraged to participate in such programs.
Keywords: Climate Change Mitigation, Command and Control, Equity-
Based Development, Low Emission Development, Market-Based
Instruments
Introduction
Indonesia is one of the countries committed to
addressing the problem of climate change. The National
Action Plan to reduce Greenhouse Gas (GHG) emissions
(RAN-GRK) has been legalized as the Presidential Decree
No. 61/2011. Emission reduction target is 26% if business
as usual, which means no international help available and
a maximum of 41% if the carbon market mechanism
works well (Jupesta, 2010). Soon after, the Local Action
Plan to reduce emissions of greenhouse gases, RAD-GRK
2010-2020, of Central Java province has also been
completed and has been legalized as the Governor
Regulation No. 43/2012. This plan focuses on mitigation
of climate change, with the goal of reducing greenhouse
gas emissions so that the environmental damage caused by
climate change can be reversed in the long term.
Unfortunately, a study initiated by GIZ concluded
that the Central Java Provincial Government is not yet
ready to implement RAD-GRK (Sugiri, 2015). The level
of preparedness of Central Java Provincial Government
in general is 3.47 (out of 5), which means a little more
than half prepared and will require much assistance.
Moreover, among the six main sectors (industry sector,
the forestry sector, transport sector, energy sector, the
waste sector and the agricultural sector), the industrial
sector is the least prepared with a score of 1.75.
The main strategy of mitigating climate change is
generally Low Emission Development (LED). This
approach seeks to keep economic growth high while
reducing the GHG emissions. Thus, the industrial sector
becomes a vital priority. Significant emissions, mainly
from large- and medium-scale manufacturing industries