Chapter 4 Teacher Responsibility Alex Kostogriz Abstract In contrast to the representation of teachers as free agents whose profes- sional knowledge, skills and ability to demonstrate a sense of mandated moral duty signify their professional identity, Kostogriz argues for an alternative understanding of professional ethics ‘as an ability to respond to others—that is, ethics as responsi- bility’, or, as he later puts it, ethics as ‘responsibility’. Kostogriz draws attention to an increasingly important tension between, on the one hand, the externally mandated expectation that teachers comply with performance indicators (standards) which con- ceive of professional ethics as ‘a moral add-on to knowledge, skills and behaviour’, and on the other, the question of whether this captures well enough just what con- stitutes the professional ethics of teachers. Significantly, the argument draws on the experiences of beginning teachers as they work to establish relations with students, revealing the situated nature of teachers’ work from which it is clear that a sense of ‘relational practice’ emerges grounded in an ethics or responsibility. What these experiences reveal is, in a sense, the poverty of externally mandated performance indicators emphasising accountability in relation to high-stakes testing (a relatively recent policy demand), while putting to one side codes of conduct drawing on broadly agreed moral principles. In Kostogriz’s view, this illustrates a turn away from the moral nature of education and the ethical in human relations such that teachers’ ‘only motivation is to enact externally mandated performance indicators and moral principles’, a situation not helped by initial teacher education programmes which defer so readily to an externally imposed representation of the professional teacher. In response, Kostogriz urges an awareness of the human subject (teacher, student), as always in the process of becoming, interconnected with each other in the same ongoing experience of being. In this relational process of self to self and self with self, we develop an ethic of responsibility to and for one another. Professional ethics of teachers has acquired increased attention in the context of standards-based reforms, indicating broader concerns about raising teacher account- A. Kostogriz (B ) Faculty of Education, Monash University, 19 Ancora Imparo Way, Clayton, VIC 3800, Australia e-mail: alexander.kostogriz@monash.edu © Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd. 2019 R. S. Webster and J. D. Whelen (eds.), Rethinking Reflection and Ethics for Teachers, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-32-9401-1_4 51