International Journal of Civil & Environmental Engineering IJCEE-IJENS Vol:10 No:01 31
109301-4747 IJCEE-IJENS © February 2010 IJENS
I J E N S
Abstract — The Nigerian construction industry produces
nearly 70% of the nation’s fixed capital formation yet its
performance within the economy has been, and continues to
be, very poor. For example, the Nigerian construction
industry’s contribution to employment has remained
consistently at 1.0% over the last decade against the World
Bank’s average observation of about 3.2% in developing
countries. The last decade however exposed the declining level
of clients’ satisfaction from the built facilities as a result of poor
quality performance in addition to the perennial problems of
time and cost overruns in the Nigerian construction industry.
This has necessitated a radical change in industry practice in
order to improve the quality of construction processes and the
level of clients’ satisfaction arising there from by devising
methodology for evaluating the quality performance of the
contractors in order to assist construction clients in selecting
quality-oriented organizations that will provide higher
quality services and products within budget and on schedule.
Therefore, the principal aim of this paper is to provide a
methodology that will improve the quality of the design and
construction processes and the level of customer satisfaction
derived there from. This paper identified quality attributes
relevant to the construction process and proposed a quality
performance evaluation model that covers both the
corporate and operational levels of a construction project. The
paper also implemented the framework in the form of an
investigative survey into the quality performance of building
contractors in Nigeria as perceived by client organizations. The
assessment was based on clients’ perception of the contractor
quality practices based on the identified quality attributes.
Index Term— Client satisfaction, Construction industry, Quality
attributes, Quality Performance,
I. INTRODUCTION
The Nigerian construction industry produces nearly 70% of
the nation‘s fixed capital formation [1].Yet its
performance within the economy has been, and continues to
be, very poor. For example, the Nigerian construction
industry‘s contribution to employment has remained
consistently at 1.0% over the last decade against the World
Bank‘s average observation of about 3.2% in developing
countries. The construction industry tends to define quality
as the ability of products and processes to conform
to the established requirements. These requirements are
established
Assoc. Prof. DR Arazi Idrus is with the Department of Civil Engineering,
Universiti Teknologi Petronas, Seri Iskandar, Tronoh, Perak, Malaysia. E-
mail: (Arazi_idrus@petronas.com.my. )
Mahmoud Sodangi is a PhD research student under the supervision of DR
Arazi Idrus at Universiti Teknologi Petronas, Seri Iskandar, Tronoh, Perak,
Malaysia. (E-mail: abbax9@yahoo.co.uk )
characteristics of a product, process or service as specified in
the contractual agreement. Quality is a persuasive concern
throughout the entire project process, as the performance of
each phase in the process will affect the performance of
subsequent phases [2]. Both [3] and [4] have suggested the
consideration of quality as a major criterion in construction
procurement systems in order to enhance the level of
competitiveness and facilitate the production of higher
quality construction,. Yet, quality remains an elusive
attribute that has been defined in many different ways. [6]
consider quality as a subset of performance, in conjunction
with productivity, safety and timeliness, while others seem
to think of it in terms of ―conformity to established
requirement s‖ or ―fitness for purpos e‖ [7] and [8]. ISO 8402
defined quality as the degree of excellence in a competitive
sense, such as reliability, serviceability, maintainability or
even individual characteristics. Similarly, the term
‗perform ance‘ can also take on different meanings depending
on the context in which it is being used. Traditionally, it has
been used to measure the effectiveness (doing the right
thing) and efficiency (doing the right thing right). Various
researchers have attributed numerous dimensions to
performance, such as quality, productivity, profitability,
safety, timeliness, growth, satisfaction, etc [9].
Therefore, in order for construction clients and end-users of
completed facilities to realize best value, the concept of
quality culture must be stressed in the industry to improve
the quality of services (design and construction processes)
and products (facilities constructed) offered by various
organizations. Accordingly, there is a need for a framework
for evaluating quality performance to assist construction
clients in selecting quality-oriented organizations that will
provide higher quality services and products within budget
and on schedule. Therefore, the principal aim of this paper is
to provide a methodology that will improve the quality of the
design and construction processes and the level of customer
satisfaction derived there from. The main objectives include
investigating project quality attributes in the design and
construction process; developing a quality performance
evaluation model that will encompass both the corporate and
project levels of a construction; and demonstrate the
application of the framework by investigating the client ‘s
perspectives of the quality performance of their contractors
at operational level.
Framework for Evaluating Quality Performance
of Contractors in Nigeria.
Arazi Bin Idrus and Mahmoud Sodangi