PHYSICAL REVIEW B 104, 224308 (2021)
Broadband coherent anti-Stokes Raman scattering for crystalline materials
Franz Hempel,
1 , * , †
Sven Reitzig ,
1 , * , ‡
Michael Rüsing ,
1
and Lukas M. Eng
1, 2
1
Institut für Angewandte Physik, Technische Universität Dresden, 01062 Dresden, Germany
2
ct.qmat: Dresden-Würzburg Cluster of Excellence–EXC 2147, TU Dresden, 01062 Dresden, Germany
(Received 5 October 2021; accepted 9 December 2021; published 30 December 2021)
Broadband coherent anti-Stokes Raman scattering (B-CARS) has emerged in recent years as a promising
chemosensitive high-speed imaging technique. B-CARS allows for the detection of vibrational sample properties
in analogy to spontaneous Raman spectroscopy, but also makes electronic sample environments accessible due to
its resonant excitation mechanism. Nevertheless, this technique has only gained interest in the biomedical field so
far, whereas CARS investigations on solid-state materials are rare and concentrate on layered, two-dimensional
materials such as graphene and hexagonal boron nitride . In this work, we discuss the specific properties of this
technique when applied to single-crystalline samples, with respect to signal generation, phase matching, and
selection rules in the model systems lithium niobate and lithium tantalate. Via polarized B-CARS measurements
and subsequent phase retrieval, we validate the predicted selection rules, unequivocally assign the phonons of
the A
1
(TO), E(TO) and A
1
(LO) branches to the detected CARS peaks, and address differences in spontaneous
Raman spectroscopy concerning peak frequencies and scattering efficiencies. We thus establish this technique
for future investigations of solid-state materials, specifically in the field of ferroelectric single crystals.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevB.104.224308
I. MOTIVATION
Microscopical spectroscopy techniques are of fundamen-
tal importance for scientific fields ranging from biology to
crystallography and material sciences due to their cost ef-
ficiency, ease of use, and versatile detection options with
spatial resolutions down to the diffraction limit. One of these
techniques, coherent anti-Stokes Raman scattering (CARS),
has seen increased use for chemosensitive imaging in re-
cent years. CARS is a coherent four-wave mixing (4WM)
Raman-scattering technique that resonantly enhances anti-
Stokes scattering processes. The third-order nonlinear CARS
process is described by a χ
(3)
tensor. Owing to its coherent
nature and spectral sensitivity, it enables chemically and struc-
turally sensitive investigations with high signal intensities.
Due to these features, CARS has gained attention primarily
for imaging of biological structures [1–3]. In the field of solid-
state materials, however, CARS has only been used for the
analysis of low-dimensional materials like carbon nanotubes
(CNTs) [4,5], graphene [6–8], and hexagonal boron nitride
(hBN) [9]. So far, no investigations of bulk single crystals
have been reported, to the best of our knowledge.
Compared with typical biological samples or two-
dimensional (2D) materials, CARS investigations within
solid, single-crystalline materials come with additional chal-
lenges. For example, inorganic crystals usually exhibit
much higher absolute refractive indexes n, as well as a
larger dispersion than the aqueous media of biological
*
These authors contributed equally to this paper.
†
franz.hempel@tu-dresden.de
‡
sven.reitzig@tu-dresden.de
tissue [e.g., n
SiC
(1064 nm) = 2.59, n
GaAs
(1064 nm) = 3.45,
whereas n
H
2
O
(1064 nm) = 1.32). This significantly impacts
the phase matching between interacting waves and causes
a stronger distortion of the incident laser beams and of the
respective focal point. Furthermore, in anisotropic crystals,
birefringence might additionally disturb the focal overlap
of the lasers, hence causing additional complexity in phase
matching. Moreover, in bulk crystals the nonlinear material
usually fills the complete focus area, while biological cell
structures are usually only several hundred nanometers to
a micron in thickness. Thus, phase matching considerations
become much more relevant to bulk crystals [10]. Solid-state
samples also may show large electronic backgrounds that
might additionally disturb the resonant vibrational CARS sig-
nal. Finally, the vibrational motions detected in crystals are
not molecular vibrations without directional orientation but
phonons that possess an inherent momentum q. While for
idealized crystals it may be assumed that only phonons with
zero momentum (q = 0) are detected, defects in real crystals
cause the detection of phonons with q = 0. These defects in
crystal structures thus provide an additional complexity in the
analysis of CARS data.
In contrast with these challenges, the CARS technique
exhibits distinct advantages in comparison to the established
technique of spontaneous Raman scattering (SR). Similar to
SR, the CARS process is sensitive to vibrational motions.
However, the χ
(3)
tensors that determine the CARS effi-
ciency obey different selection rules, providing advantages
for certain scenarios [11], and enable a higher sensitivity to
geometry changes in the scattering process when compared
with SR [12]. Furthermore, whereas SR shows a comparably
low scattering efficiency and thus requires long acquisition
times in regard to hyperspectral imaging, the nonlinear nature
of CARS allows a much faster spectral acquisition, especially
2469-9950/2021/104(22)/224308(11) 224308-1 ©2021 American Physical Society