Those Days Are Gone Forever: Steely Dan’s Grumpy Old White
Guys’ Blues
Kevin Fellezs
Music/African American and African Diaspora Studies, Columbia University, New York, NY, USA
ABSTRACT
Steely Dan has always been a grumpy old guy’s band. In this essay, I
listen to the ways in which Becker and Fagen turn their critical
misandry on middle-aged American boomer generation males,
adrift in vats of self-pity, marinating in melancholy and regret, and
fermenting inexorably into elderly obsolescence. The duo masked
their baleful assessment of white masculinist anxieties in music
which blended jazz and rock sensibilities painstakingly polished to
a smooth glossy aural sheen – all of which articulated an adultifca-
tion of rock music culture in the 1970s.
Keywords
Middle-aged; jazz; white
masculinity; nostalgia
When men reach the age of forty or fifty, they tend to observe a curious change. They
discover that most of the individuals with whom they grew up and maintained contact now
behave in a disturbed manner. One may stop working so that his business fails; another may
break his marriage, though the fault does not lie with his wife; and yet another may embezzle
money. Even those individuals who show no such striking behavioral changes still show
signs of degeneration. Conversation with them becomes shallow, threadbare, and boastful.
Previously the aging individual found mental stimulus in others but now he feels that he is
almost the only one to present objective interest. (Adorno, 2000, “Adorno, 2000” 240).
Steely Dan has always been a grumpy old guy’s band. “Reelin’ In the Years,” the second
single from the band’s 1972 debut album, Can’t Buy A Thrill, written when they were in
their twenties, offered the world-weary perspective of someone far older, perhaps none
the wiser but certainly more experienced. Time did not mellow them. If anything, Walter
Becker and Donald Fagen only hardened Steely Dan’s perspective as cynical white male
boomer curmudgeons, putting to music Adorno’s dour assessment of the middle-aged
male bourgeoisie as described in the epigraph (with the duo replacing Adorno’s still-vital
“aging individual” observing his “shallow, threadbare” peers). In this essay, I listen to the
ways in which Becker and Fagen turn their critical misandry on middle-aged American
boomer generation males, adrift in vats of self-pity, marinating in melancholy and regret,
and fermenting inexorably into elderly obsolescence. The duo masked their baleful
assessment of white masculinist anxieties in music which blended jazz and rock sensi-
bilities painstakingly polished to a smooth glossy aural sheen – all of which articulated an
adultification of rock music culture in the 1970s.
CONTACT Kevin Fellezs kf2362@columbia.edu Music/African American and African Diaspora Studies, Columbia
University, 438 West 116th Street #34, New York, NY 10027
ROCK MUSIC STUDIES
https://doi.org/10.1080/19401159.2022.2008164
© 2021 Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group