15
A Comparison of Corporate Social
Responsibility Reporting in the United
States, Germany and Australia
Stephen Chen and Petra Bouvain
Introduction
Corporate social responsibility (CSR) reporting is not mandatory in most
countries, but has been adopted by many large companies from around
the world.The terms corporate social responsibility, global citizenship and
sustainability can now be found in the corporate reports and websites of
large and small corporations from around the world. However, consider-
able variation exists among firms worldwide. While some companies (e.g.
Henkel, BHP, Johnson and Johnson)have a long-standing tradition in report-
ing information and have created separate internet sites to show all facets of
their corporate responsibility and sustainability , other companies provide
only limited information, in many cases related to corporate giving and
sponsorship, or in some cases no information at all.
CSR reporting and corporate governance are obviously related since corpo-
rate reporting is both an input to and a product of the corporate governance
process (Bebbington, 2004). It could also be argued, taking a social construc-
tionist perspective, that CSR reporting is a means of influencing how others
view and see the corporation and corporate governance issues (Parker, 2007).
To the extent that one observes differences in corporate governance, one
would, therefore, also expect to observe differences in CSR reporting. This
argument does seem to be borne out by the few studies that have exam-
ined this issue. For instance, Aguilera and Cuervo-Cazurra (2004) contrast
CSR reporting in the United States and the United Kingdom and argue that
national differences in CSR can be related to differences in corporate gov-
ernance systems. Because business organizations are embedded in different
national business systems and different corporate governance systems, they
will experience divergent degrees of internal and external pressures to engage
in social responsibility initiatives (Logsdon and Wood, 2005; Matten and
Crane, 2005).
266
R. Strange et al. (eds.), Corporate Governance and International Business
© Palgrave Macmillan, a division of Macmillan Publishers Limited 2008