VOL. 15, NO. 5, MARCH 2020 ISSN 1819-6608
ARPN Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences
©2006-2020 Asian Research Publishing Network (ARPN). All rights reserved.
www.arpnjournals.com
607
OPTIMIZATION OF HIGH-FREQUENCY RESISTANCE WELDING
PROCESS USING MECHANICAL PROPERTY OF FINNED TUBE
SA-192 STEEL
Montri Sangsuriyun
1
, Prayoon Surin
1
and Krittee Eidhed
2
1
Department of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, Faculty of Engineering, Pathumwan Institute of Technology, Bangkok, Thailand
2
Faculty of Engineering, King Mongkut’s University of Technology North Bangkok, Bangkok, Thailand
E-Mail: montri.sang@npuac.th
ABSTRACT
The objective of this study is to investigate the effects of welding parameters in the welding process on the
mechanical properties and micro structure to compare the design of experiment (DOE) for the high-frequency resistance
welding process (HFRW) of ASTM SA-192high-carbon steel. The different butt weld T joints of finned-tubes were
prepared by varying the welding parameters, including current (A), voltage (kV) and frequency (rpm) which were also
related to the heat input and mechanical properties. DOE analysis of the welding parameters was performed at 9A, 13kV,
250 rpm and heat input of 474 J/mm. The results showed that the ultimate tensile strength was 749 MPa which meets the
standard requirements of the Association of Finned Tube Manufacturers and is at a good level in the production
viewpoint.However, the examination of the micro-and macrostructure of the weld line using an inverted microscope
showed some melting on the specimens and it was found that some specimens had high weld width and weld depth. In
addition, the tensile strength was also higher . However, too high tensile strength was changed the material structure, the
cause of HAZ. Through the validation of the welding process which was compared to the fatigue strength, the following
results were indicated: (1) the ultimate tensile strength at the highest tensile stress was not the ultimate fatigue strength and
the heat input affected the weld width and weld depth of the weld line . (2) In the welding process, the weld width and weld
depth must be also considered since they can affect the specimen failure during the experiment . Therefore, extreme care
must be taken when using a high-frequency resistance welding process.
Keywords: welding parameters, mechanical property, resistance welding process, finned-tubes.
1. INTRODUCTION
There are many types of stainless-steel heat
exchangers, such as shell and tube heat exchanger, plate
heat exchanger and finned tube heat exchanger, etc. The
finned tube heat exchanger is widely used and has a
variety of applications in industries such as oil refineries,
power plants and petrochemical industry due to the
advantages of a finned pipe which can improve heat
dissipation by increasing heat transfer surface area. Thus,
it reduces the number of pipes and related equipment
sizes, which can also reduce project costs [1]. The high-
frequency resistance welding (HFRW) process is
considered as the resistance welding that uses high-
frequency current in the welding process. HFRW can
generate heat and relies on the compression force in
welding the specimen. Besides, controlling the welding
speed results in heat conduction during the welding
process, which affects the weld depth of the material. If
the welding speed decreases, the heat inside the specimen
increases, increasing the weld depth of the material [2, 3].
A common problem in the heat exchange of stainless steel
is the cracks in the tube and the fin surface. These cracks
are caused by stress corrosion cracking (SCC). Local
stress level resulting from the combination of loads affects
the fracture in the material. Although stainless steel has
excellent resistance to fatigue or corrosion, high heat or
temperature in the welding process can lead to cracks and
risk of corrosion. SCC is induced by stress along with the
exposure of the corrosive environment [4, 5, 6]. In
addition, fatigue caused by external forces and vibration
due to the environment affects the optimization of welding
parameters or welding processes, because unsuitable
parameters accelerate cracking and corrosion [7, 8].
Therefore, this study aimed at determining the
optimum parameters by using the Design of Experiment
(DOE) principle for the high-frequency resistance welding
process and the comparison the mechanical properties of
the material, including tensile stress, fatigue and macro-
and microstructure of SA-192 finned tube, the causes of
failure in welding of pipe and fin.
2. EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE
2.1 Materials and welding standards
In this study, the finned tube heat exchanger was
investigated. This heat exchanger was made of ASTM SA-
192 high-carbon steel with 0.6-0.18% C, 0.27-0.63% Mn,
0.25% Si, 0.035% P and 0.035% Sand with 0.83mm
diameter and 3.2 mm wall thickness. The fin was 16mm
high and 1mm thick shown in Figure-1. The tests were
conducted in accordance with the finned tube production
standard [9].