Looked-after children and their birth families: using
sociology to explore changing relationships, hidden
histories and nomadic childhoods
Sally Holland* and Anne Crowley†
*Reader, †Honorary Lecturer, School of Social Sciences, Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK
Correspondence:
Sally Holland,
School of Social Sciences,
Cardiff University,
Glamorgan Building,
King Edward VII Avenue,
Cardiff CF103WT,
UK
E-mail: Hollands1@cf.ac.uk
Keywords: care experiences, foster
care, looked-after children, loss and
separation, theoretical issues
Accepted for publication:
September 2012
ABSTRACT
This paper draws on a series of life-history interviews with 16 young
adults who were all formerly looked-after children. Eight young men
and eight young women aged 17 to 25 took part in the study in Wales,
UK.They had experienced a wide range of circumstances at home, in
care and after care. They were contacted through a self-advocacy
organization and other care leavers’ groups. The paper explores how
insights from the sociology of the family can serve to enhance under-
standings of these young people’s life stories and, additionally, how
their lived experiences can contribute to this sociological field. Key
themes explored in the paper include the emotional co-presence of
the birth family for children living in substitute care, the dynamic
nature of experiences and perceptions of family relationships through
the life course, the importance of siblings and the insightful reflec-
tions of participants on the challenges of learning to ‘do’ family across
childhoods marked by nomadism. The paper concludes that a holistic
theoretical approach that embraces ‘psy’ and sociological under-
standings of families and relationships will be most productive for
researchers, practitioners and families.
INTRODUCTION
Families and relationships are central to social work
practice. This paper explores the strengths and limita-
tions of engaging with theoretical and empirical
writing from the field of sociology of the family, and
related fields of sociologies of intimacy, personal life
and childhoods, in order to enhance our understand-
ings of families in adversity. Specifically, the paper
presents data from a study of care leavers’ accounts of
critical moments in their life histories. We present
analysis relating to relationships with birth family
members and placement moves as particularly impor-
tant exemplars of the role of ‘family’ in these young
people’s lives.
The study took place inWales, UK. In March 2011,
there were 5145 looked-after children inWales, a rate
of 87 per 10 000 population aged under 18 (Welsh
Government 2011). The rates are significantly higher
than in England, where 59 per 10 000 are looked after
(Harker 2012). The number of looked-after children
in Wales has increased by 20% over the last 5 years
and 59% came to be looked after for reasons of abuse
or neglect. Of relevance to the findings in this paper,
9% of looked-after children had three or more place-
ment moves in the last year, 9% were placed with their
parents or another with parental responsibility and
80% were in foster care (Welsh Government 2011).
Looked-after children represent a significant policy
concern in Wales and one of the key aims of the
recently introduced statutory Integrated Family
Support Services is to keep families together (Welsh
Assembly Government 2010). Nonetheless, Forrester
et al. (2009) have argued that, in view of consistent
research findings showing that children often enter
public care with serious problems but tend to improve
while in care, English andWelsh policy-makers should
aim to provide more care as a positive family support
doi:10.1111/cfs.12032
57 Child and Family Social Work 2013, 18, pp 57–66 © 2013 Blackwell Publishing Ltd