VOL. 8, NO. 1, JANUARY 2013 ISSN 1819-6608
ARPN Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences
© 2006-2013 Asian Research Publishing Network (ARPN). All rights reserved.
www.arpnjournals.com
1
EXAMINING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF RAINWATER COLLECTION
SYSTEMS IN A NIGERIAN LEPER COLONY USING THE
BEHAVIOURAL MODEL
Olaoye Rebecca A.
1
, Coker Akinwale O.
1
, Sridhar Mynepalli K.
1
and Adewole Esan M.
2
1
Department of Civil Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, University of Ibadan, Oyo State, Nigeria
2
Department of Civil Engineering, Faculty of Engineering and Technology, Ladoke Akintola University of Technology,
Ogbomoso, Nigeria
E-mail: radeshiyan@yahoo.com ,
ABSTRACT
Rainwater from roof catchments can be a valuable source of water and can be quite safe to drink when stored in a
properly installed and well maintained water storage system. It is noteworthy to observe the capacity intended for rainwater
storage because this factor is a determinant to both its initial cost of construction and its effectiveness, especially during the
dry season for the isolated lepers who are sited outskirts of towns and cities where the water mains does not get to. This
paper examines the effectiveness of rainwater collection systems in a Nigerian leper colony using behavioral method, such
that the relationship between the storage and the utility or demand was punctuated in terms of water saving efficiency. The
data obtained were used to mathematically simulate the model algorithms using the time interval of an hour, a day and a
month. The detailed analysis for the application of these time interval models were expressed in a dimensionless ratio
known as the storage fraction, S/AR, where S = storage capacity (m³), A = roof area (m²), and R = average annual rainfall
(m). The values obtained for the water saving efficiency using the YAS and the YBS algorithms shows that the YBS gives
an exaggerated value for the data plots while the YAS operating algorithm showed a conservative estimate and could be
use as a standard of comparison and calibration for other models. The hourly models can therefore be most effective for
relatively small stores with storage fractions less than 0.014. Daily models can be used more effectively for stores with
storage factions above 0.014 while the monthly time model for store capacities with storage fractions greater than 0.13.
Keywords: Rainwater harvesting, collection systems, roof catchment, water saving efficiency, sustainable water source.
List of symbols
R Average annual rainfall (m)
Yt Yield (m³)
Dt Demand (m³)
Vt Volume of rainwater (m³)
Vt-1 Volume of water in tank from the time interval
t–1(m³)
Qt Runoff into tank (m³)
S Capacity of the tank/ storage capacity (m³)
A Roof area (m²)
D Annual demand (m³/yr)
ET Water saving efficiency at time t
YAS Yield after spillage
YBS Yield before spillage
t Time interval (hour, day, month)
1. INTRODUCTION
A safe and potable water is yearned for globally,
one which can be easily harnessed when needed but
nevertheless this necessity has proved somewhat difficult
for the government and the non-governmental
organisations who from day to day strife to meet the daily
requirements of the masses. Many lepers communities all
over the world are approaching the limits of their
traditional water resources as thousands of lepers
throughout the world still do not have access to adequate
water a basic necessity for well being and development.
The situation is even direr in developing country like
Nigeria [1, 2, 3, and 4] where even the towns and cities
lack adequate water supply [5, 6]. On the other hand,
rainwater harvesting has drawn increased attention in
many parts of the world as an economic and sustainable
water source both for potable and non-potable use [7].
Hence the collection of rainwater from roof catchments
and storage is a viable method of reducing water scarcity
in leper colonies all over the world. As a general rule,
rainfall should be over 50 mm/month for at least half a
year or 300 mm/year to make Rain Water Harvesting
environmentally feasible [8].
Without extensive treatment required rainwater
can be suitable for a range of household chore such as
drinking, WC flushing, clothes washing, garden
irrrigation, and in some cases bathing. Rainwater
harvesting has maintained its importance as water source
for small scale agriculture and as a primary water source
in the remote locations in the rural areas and islands, so
this could be applicable for the lepers who are sited
outskirts of cities where the water mains are inaccessible
[9, 10]. Rainwater harvesting has become a popular
supplement for potable water to reduce the demand on the
conventional water supplies even in the cities where the
surface water is polluted or the groundwater is over
extracted due to rapid increase in population. The cost of
rainwater collection tend to be quite small but the largest
economic consideration is the initial capital cost to
construct the collection system. In lepers’ colony, rural
areas and even in some urban households where rainwater
is valued it could be harnessed with bowls, buckets, jerry
cans, tanks etc. But in the case where there is need to
utilize this natural water source maximally, the