J Neurosurg: Pediatrics / Volume 14 / November 2014
J Neurosurg Pediatrics 14:495–500, 2014
495
©AANS, 2014
B
rainstem dysfunction is the most common cause
of death in newborns with myelomeningocele
(MMC).
9
Most newborns with MMC have associ-
ated Chiari Type II malformation. Brainstem dysfunction
occurs in 20% of patients with MMC
23
and is tradition-
ally considered to arise from brainstem dysgenesis in Chi-
ari Type II malformation and resultant mechanical stress
on the brainstem and cranial nerves.
7,24
However, similar
symptoms have been reported in MMC in the absence of
Chiari Type II malformation.
20
Surgical treatment of brain-
stem dysfunction in these patients is controversial.
2,15,23
Some surgeons advocate early craniocervical decompres-
sion in patients who become symptomatic,
23,25,26,31
par-
ticularly because of the poor prognosis for children who
develop bilateral vocal cord paralysis.
22,34
Unfortunately,
prediction of symptom development remains diffcult.
Past researchers have investigated the utility of audi-
tory function testing for predicting symptom development
in children with MMC. Most patients with MMC have
abnormal results on auditory brainstem response (ABR)
testing, with prolonged interpeak latencies (IPLs)
1,14,33
re-
fecting slow peripheral
12,18,21
and central
5,6,18,19,21
auditory
neurotransmission. Normalization of central auditory
function over time, coupled with progressively worsening
peripheral auditory function, suggests intrinsic brainstem
improvement with simultaneous cranial nerve stretch-
ing.
18,21
Some authors have had success correlating ABR
results with symptoms,
14,30,33
though not in older children.
5
Case reports describe ABR improvement after craniocer-
vical decompression.
10,29
Automated ABR testing is commonly used in the uni-
versal newborn hearing screening (NHS) programs that
were introduced throughout the United States in the mid-
to late 1990s.
28
These programs were designed to identify
hearing loss early by screening newborns before hospital
discharge. Most studies of auditory impairment in MMC
were published before the advent of universal NHS, and no
prior research has examined whether NHS failure predicts
development of brainstem dysfunction in these patients.
Prognostic value of newborn hearing screening in
patients with myelomeningocele
Clinical article
DaviD Satzer, B.a., anD Daniel J. Guillaume, m.D.
Department of Neurosurgery, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota
Object. Brainstem dysfunction occurs in a minority of patients with myelomeningocele (MMC), most of whom
have Chiari Type II malformation. Some surgeons advocate early identifcation of these patients for craniocervical
decompression to avoid signifcant mortality. The auditory brainstem response has been found to be abnormal in
most children with MMC. The present study examines whether failure of routine newborn hearing screening (NHS)
predicts brainstem dysfunction in MMC patients.
Methods. The charts of 40 newborns with MMC and 50 newborns without MMC who stayed in the neonatal
intensive care unit were reviewed. Results of NHS, brainstem symptoms, birth demographics, and surgical history
were retrospectively examined. Differences in the presence and onset of brainstem symptoms by NHS result were
assessed.
Results. Failure of NHS was more common among newborns with MMC who developed brainstem symptoms
(31%, 4 of 13 patients) than among newborns without MMC (0%, 0 of 50 patients; p = 0.001). Among the 40 new-
borns with MMC, brainstem symptoms were more common in those who failed NHS (80%, 4 of 5 patients) than in
those who passed (26%, 9 of 35 patients; p = 0.031). Respiratory symptom onset occurred later in patients who failed
NHS (median 16 months) than among those who passed (median 0 months; p = 0.022). The positive and negative
predictive values of NHS for brainstem dysfunction in MMC were 0.80 and 0.74, respectively.
Conclusions. Results of NHS may help predict future brainstem dysfunction in patients with MMC and may be
useful to incorporate into prognostic assessment and surgical decision making.
(http://thejns.org/doi/abs/10.3171/2014.7.PEDS14168)
Key WorDS • newborn hearing screening • myelomeningocele • congenital •
brainstem dysfunction
Abbreviations used in this paper: ABR = auditory brainstem
response; EMR = electronic medical record; IPL = interpeak laten-
cy; MMC = myelomeningocele; NHS = newborn hearing screening;
NICU = neonatal intensive care unit; OAE = otoacoustic emissions.