154 Journal of Reviews on Global Economics, 2016, 5, 154-164
E-ISSN: 1929-7092/16 © 2016 Lifescience Global
Causality between Monetary Expansion and the Price Level in India
since 1950s – A Re-Examination
Sanjib Debnath and Ritwik Mazumder
*
Department of Economics, Assam University, Silchar, Assam 788011, India
Abstract: This paper has tested short run causality between broad money supply and whole-sale price index (WPI) in
India during 1951-2013 adopting a Toda-Yamamoto (1995) modified Granger causality approach under a VAR
environment. Exponentially detrended annual time series data on broad money supply and the whole-sale price index
are used for this purpose. Alternative tests for structural breaks reveal significant but dissimilar breaks in the variables.
The empirical results are suggestive of a uni-directional causality from broad money supply to WPI. The study further
finds that broad money supply and WPI in India have a long-run co-integrating relationship and short run causal relations
could hence be expected.
Keywords: Broad money supply, WPI, Modified Granger Causality, Toda-Yamamoto (1995) and VAR.
1. INTRODUCTION
Over the years, empirical studies on monetary
expansion and inflation or between money supply and
the price level have received significant attention in
developing countries. This is perhaps because most of
these nations today have a significant poor population
and a burgeoning middle class and inflation hurts these
groups the most. Consequently the key policy objective
of both monetary and fiscal authorities in such
countries is to control inflation (i.e., maintain price
stability) without jeopardising the growth potentials. The
monetary authorities truly recognise both the
theoretical and empirical validities of money supply –
price level inter-linkage which compels them to adopt
tighter monetary policies during periods of high
inflation. Further welfare states are aware about the
social and economic costs of inflation which motivate
them to fix price stability as the primary goal of
macroeconomic policy. Price volatility creates
uncertainties, lowers the real returns to savings and
investments, and is detrimental for economic growth.
The literature on money-inflation nexus in India
recognizes that unwarranted growth of money supply
has been one of the key factors behind the inflationary
spells experienced since the 1950s. Monetary
expansion or increase in money supply was triggered
by central government borrowings from the Reserve
Bank of India (Pattnaik and Samantaraya 2006; Reddy
1999). Indian economists maintain that the factor
primarily accountable for the excessive growth of
money supply and thus inflationary spells experienced
in India, has been the large scale resort to deficit
financing by the central government. This argument led
*Address of correspondence to this author at the Department of Economics,
Assam University, Silchar, Assam 788011, India; Tel: 91-03842-270853;
Fax: 91-03842-270802; E-mail: r_itwikm@yahoo.com
JEL Classification: C32, E50, E52, E59.
to the discontinuation of automatic monetisation of debt
by the RBI since 1997. Among the significant empirical
contributions in this area for the Indian economy in
recent years, the studies by Rangarajan and Arif
(1990), Jadav and Singh (1990), Srimany and Samanta
(1998), Parida et al. (2001), Rangarajan (2001),
D’Souza (2003), Mohan (2008), Mishra and Mishra
(2009), Singh and Kalirajan (2006 and 2007) are
important in view of their economic as well as
methodological robustness. However short period
analyses in the above studies may question the
statistical reliability of the test results as because
multiple business cycles across decades are not
captured.
The present study however focuses entirely on
testing for short run causality between broad money
supply and whole-sale price index (WPI) in India during
1951-2013 adopting a Toda-Yamamoto (1995)
modified Granger causality approach under a VAR
environment. In particular the study examines whether
broad money supply expansion has been inflationary in
India. Exponentially detrended annual time series data
on broad money supply and the whole-sale price index
are used. Structural break unit root tests along with
structural break dates are also determined. The paper
is written in the following sections. After a brief
introduction to issues relating to money-inflation nexus
in India in section 1, data sources and econometric
issues are discussed in section 2. Section 3 presents
the analysis of empirical results, followed by a very
brief summary and conclusions in section 4.
2. METHODOLOGY AND DATA
2.1. Variable Selection and Detrending
The direction of causality between money and
prices is justified by the monetarist school. The