Political Geography 95 (2022) 102562
Available online 22 January 2022
0962-6298/© 2021 Published by Elsevier Ltd.
Geographies of precarity and violence in the Kurdish kolberi
underground economy
Sanan Moradi
*
, Adam C. Morse, Alexander B. Murphy, Delaram Pakru
1, 2
, Shehabad H.
1, 2
Department of Geography, University of Oregon, Eugene, OR, USA
A R T I C L E INFO
Keywords:
Kolber
Underground economy
Precarity
Violence
Biopolitics
Borders
Borderlands
Kurds
Kurdistan
Iran
ABSTRACT
This paper investigates the precarious lives of the Kurdish kolbers, underground laborers who transport cargo on
their backs across Iran’s border with Iraq. Throughout their arduous journeys, kolbers experience various forms
of violence, including direct shooting by border guards. Findings from interviews with the kolbers indicate that
kolberi, a strenuous, dangerous, precarious type of labor, is a response to pervasive unemployment in Iranian
Kurdistan (Rojhelat), and a long-term consequence of the Iranian state’s systematic economic disinvestment in
the Kurdish region. Although kolbers assert agency within their labor at localized scales, the social organization
of kolberi is a reaction to the Iranian state’s biopolitical strategies of economic disinvestment and violence.
Drawing on a biopolitical framework, we illustrate the analytical interconnections among the economic
marginalization of Rojhelat, violence against the kolbers, and the kolbers’ precarious lives. The article offers
ideas for future research that come out of our examination of the complexities of kolberi—an examination that
demonstrates the importance of incorporating political-economic, ethno-territorial, and biopolitical factors in
analyses of underground border exchanges and precarious marginalized lives.
1. Introduction
In the absence of job opportunities in his Kurdish town, Simko had no
choice but to do kolberi
3
to support his family. Kolberi refers to an
extremely strenuous and precarious form of labor that involves Kurdish
kolbers carrying loads of goods from Iraq and Turkey across the border
into Iran on their backs.
4
Each load can weigh between 30 and 80 kg
(66–176 lb), and the routes the kolbers travel range from 5 to 15 km (3–9
mi)—traversing highly rugged terrain. Journeys typically involve mul-
tiple life-threatening dangers.
The challenges kolberi presents are well illustrated by an incident on
the foggy evening of November 20, 2017, when Simko and his group of
14 fellow kolbers were on their way to cross the border into Iraq to pick
up loads. Just a few hundred meters before reaching the borderline, his
group was ambushed and came under fre by Iranian border guards. In
the foggy confusion, the kolbers scattered, feeing for their lives. Bullets
seemed to be coming from everywhere and out of nowhere. Simko was
shot frst in the left leg. Then, as he was pleading, he was shot again, this
time in the right hand and lower back, destroying his kidney and
injuring his spinal cord. In the chaos, another kolber, H. Moradi,
5
was
killed by bullets in the head. The border guards retrieved Simko’s
injured body, dragged him on the ground, and then tossed him “like a
bag of grains” into the back of the military truck (interview #20, 2019).
Simko had pleaded for the border guards to take him to a hospital,
but instead they tortured and verbally abused him. One of the border
guards threatened Simko at gunpoint, telling him that he “would be sent
to where his [dead] friend had gone, if he spoke too much.” Because of
his injuries, Simko was paralyzed in both legs. The court also convicted
Simko of crossing the border illegally and “undermining national secu-
rity,” even though he had been ambushed inside Iran’s borders. With no
insurance or income, and mounting medical bills and court fnes, Simko
and his family lead extremely precarious lives, relying on community
* Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: smoradi@uoregon.edu (S. Moradi), amorse2@uoregon.edu (A.C. Morse), abmurphy@uoregon.edu (A.B. Murphy).
1
The two co-authors of this article who contributed from inside Iran have used pseudonyms to protect their own anonymity.
2
Independent scholar Kurdistan, Iran
3
Kolberi is a Kurdish word that literally means ‘carrying on one’s back’ (kol, meaning ‘upper back; ’ and berî, from the verb birdin, meaning ‘carrying, taking from
one place to another’).
4
See also Bozcali (2019), and Soleimani and Mohammadpour (2020b).
5
No relation to the author.
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Political Geography
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/polgeo
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polgeo.2021.102562
Received 16 August 2020; Received in revised form 3 August 2021; Accepted 7 December 2021